You are reading an exclusive quartz story, which is available to all readers for a limited period.
To unlock all quartz access, please visit our membership page.
On a weekday balmy evening around when the spring was melting until summer, my partner and I made plans after the work. We chose a place in my neighborhood, which happens next to the boys' stadium. As we spent our beer and talking about the week, my partner, Ben, saw two of our friends, Tom and Hannah, on their way to a football match. He brought them down and invited them to come before the open field.
It would be a perfectly forgotten afternoon – normal and normal. DC is small enough that it is not too uncommon to run in friends. We didn't see Tom and Hannah for a while, and I knew Tom was visiting his hometown in Connecticut. “How is your family doing?” I asked.
Tom and Hannah looked.
“Actually, yes,” he said.
A few months ago, he shared, his father suddenly lost his short-term memory. He was doing something like cooking a meal and forgetting what he was doing; he didn't put the stove in and leave the room, or he was driving and forget where he was going. He was only 61.
Now Tom's father was retiring from a job in a trucking company, and he lived at home with his wife Tom's mother. She was caring for him while watching his grandchild, Tom's niece and nephew, younger than 6. Tom's biggest visit to Connecticut was to talk to his sisters, mother and father about how they had to help him take care of him. Tom told me that he decided to quit his job as a pharmacist to move up with his family during the summer while making their new living arrangements.
He was heavy on a small speech. I remember that I expressed empathy and concern, and asked some questions about his father's overall health. Doctors had no idea so far what was wrong: there was no prior memory loss, no family history of dementia.
The journalist wanted me to ask questions. I have been researching dementia-related research long enough to find out that mental problems were unlikely before 65 well. But there was some of them explanation. Memory problems usually involve Alzheimer's problems, but the short-term loss seemed unusual. Vascular dementia maybe?
The friend told me, thankfully, for me to close. We listened to Tom, and offered any support we could do and Tom had gone in the coming months. Eventually, we said our blessings; They went to the game, and Ben and I went home.
It was a frightening conversation, and a shame. I thought I was a manual chair expert in the current state of neurodegenerative health; I read the newest scientific papers as they came out, and I talked to the best neurologists. At that point, even if scientists did not get all the answers to prevent or treat dementia, they did. Biometrics seemed to be promising to detect mild cognitive impairment earlier than therapies targeting neurological inflammation or microbial pathogens. Scientists only had to design and run experiments, and write up the papers so I could report on them.
When I spoke to Tom, I realized that no matter how far science came, there was a whole set of problems that science would never be able to solve: What really happens you. No matter how far science progresses in the next 10 or 20 years or even 100 years, it will never be possible to take the steps if you have to talk about dementia and deal with it yourself. In my report, I have ignored these questions conveniently, as they have not been involved in a laboratory tribunal, and therefore for me.
But Tom and his father are only a few years older than me and my mother, respectively. Tom's father is the same age as me. Dementia was truly real, a burden that one of my friends may be carrying. And I knew next to nothing about it.
I think there are no questions without answers: There's just a question to find out about the right expert. If scientists could not say to me the best way to look after your loving person who has recently been diagnosed with dementia, there must be doctors or policy experts. I showed that the American Gerontological Society was connected to Austin, Texas loads people with answers.
Walter Dawson, a public health policy expert currently at the Global Brain Health Institute in San Francisco, was one of them. At the age of 8, Dawson began caring for his father, who developed Alzheimer's disease.
In an interview at the conference, I asked Dawson what changes could help patients and their families manage better. “If we can detect cognitive impairment at an earlier stage, there is a clear benefit for individuals living with dementia,” he said. “It is an opportunity to initiate care planning and disease management at an earlier stage in the disease process.” He recalled research from 2014, where a UK-based group found that a person with dementia could save 17% of their annual costs if diagnosis a few years earlier than most people are diagnosed today.
Except if early diagnosis is not available to many people. “It is an equity and access issue,” said Dawson. In the US, there is a shortage of psychiatrists – doctors who specialize in the treatment of older adults with multiple chronic conditions – and neurologists. Patients may have to wait up to six months for an appointment, for example, or drive 75 miles away.
If we could, we will be starting in our 20s, 30s, and 40s thinking about what we want in the future.
And when they're there, maybe they don't want to give up brain health. There is a stigma around dementia and other cognitive issues. Many people think that they can't give up their healthcare workers in case they get a diagnosis they don't want to hear, or lose their independence. Doctors may not have better: A recent study by the Alzheimer's Society, an advocacy group, found that only about 16% of older people reported having received regular screening (pdf). I like it, Who is going to dance the other person? Joanne Pike, the Alzheimer's Society chief programming officer, said.
The same reason for this stigma is that it is so difficult to give up cognitive health to an older adult you love. While you have online information packs about the importance of having these conversations, it is very likely that the information is set down. how.
I asked Dawson some distinctive people, eagerly thinking that there was some kind of script there. He paused. It was not just focusing on the needs of the individual, he said. His best advice was to start thinking about him as soon as possible. “If we could, we could start our 20s, 30s, and 40s thinking about what we want in the future,” he said. Pike changed this sentiment. If your loving person refuses to ask questions about their cognition first, she said, try to try to go back and wait another time.
This is not the kind of concrete answer I expected. As I thought of who might be the right expert for my question, I met that I spoke to almost two days every day: My parents.
When my mother's mother was diagnosed with dementia 20 years ago, my parents were part of her primary carers, along with my mother's two sisters. I was only 7 at a time; I remember visiting Grandpa John in a home with assistance, and eventually a nursing home (he was frightened), but not much else. However, my parents certainly did this conversation. And because they are both chemists, they are likely to respond to some of the scientific specificities I wanted.
“Do you think I could interview you about caring for Grandpa John?” I sent my mom a text. “Or face their dementia?”
My parents agreed. I called more than a speaker, and when I put the question up again, my mother laughed: “It doesn't work like that. No ting to face you '' 'For my grandfather, she said, it would be like a toddler. “You could do the same conversation more than once and you might think it was left with a sense of what would happen, but it doesn't remember.” T
Ultimately, children learn and toddlers over time. Grandpa did not do John. He was blamed for some of his early memory loss when he had difficulty hearing; instead of acknowledging that he forgot something, he said he had never heard of information. My parents didn't notice that something was really wrong when John was driving up to visit them from Florida to Pennsylvania. He lost the way, and he was not able to learn how to read the map. Finally, he went to a gas station and handed his cell phone to the manager, who told my dad where to go.
He was found to have dementia within a year. My parents started making arrangements for him to live in a living aid facility. They told him that he was being tested to see if he liked it, when they knew he was there for as long as he could. He signed paperwork to carry out his power of attorney, but he didn't really know what was happening, they said. He was already too ill.
Finally, having started to go astray in the complex and entering other apartments, my parents, with the approval of my mother's siblings and their spouses, transferred to a nursing home. Back then, it cost about $ 6,000 a month, my mother remembered, although it is probably more like $ 10,000 today. They used Grandpa savings to cover the costs. It was enough that he lived until he died, although there was nothing left for them to inherit.
There was no early planning for Grandpa John, my parents said, without any real conversation; They must act. And even today, that is the same position that most families with families with dementia go up.
Tom and his family found themselves acting on one day in January 2019. “He asked my mom and I asked the same question again and again,” said Tom. His mother knew that this was unusual, and she asked his father's office to ask his keepers had nothing strange. They were. His mother indicated that Tom's father was driving straight to his primary care provider, who called an ambulance.
Tom's father has diabetes, and in the emergency room, the doctors brought attention to one of his medications in particular. He reduced his blood sugar but not his ketone, which is acidic; if too many are in the blood, the pH of the blood can be lowered, a potentially fatal condition known as diabetic kooididosis. He stayed in hospital for four days getting his levels back.
His primary care doctor hoped that the short-term memory problems would resolve themselves with ketosis.
“My mum told you immediately that we realized there was no memory,” said Tom later, in an interview in November. It took longer to convince the doctors; They stayed a few months to find out if he would return. When it was not, Thomas's family started bringing his father from a specialist to a specialist. “I have never sought a diagnosis,” said Tom: Because of his background as a pharmacist, he suspects that the diabetic ketoacidosis caused some permanent brain damage. It is likely that he would not show brain tests or scan because he was not studied.
“If I gave my mother a real diagnosis, she would have helped her find the story,” he said. But when it came to light that doctors were unlikely to give them concrete answers, Tom decided that he had to go home to be his family during the summer.
His parents moved with his sister to try to manage his father's care in April; it was not suitable. Tom helped them move into a bigger house they shared with his brother. In early November, Tom MRI's father at Yale, received a hospital about 30 minutes, still searching for answers.
Meanwhile, Tom's family completely renovated his father's medicines for diabetes, which simplified what they could do to avoid future emergencies. The house now has sticky notes to help his father keep track of his daily activities, including taking his medicine and remembering everyone's schedule for the day.
They also decided to take care of end-of-life planning when they were able. While Tom's father has lost his short-term memory, he is well enough to have an agency in relation to these major decisions. Tom's mom now has a legal power of attorney for his father; Tom has a medical power of attorney.
It could be argued that some of the most important steps a family can take with early dementia or a cognitive impairment diagnosis, caring for legal matters like this. Money matters – the type of care you need later in life, and how you will pay for it. Both the Alzheimer's Society and the American Association of Retired People have resources that set out some of the specific steps involved, but all still require contact with a lawyer. These processes can take months, and they are complicated.
Tom's family experience was unique in that it happened so quickly – within a day. And my own family happened twenty years ago, when they got too late a diagnosis. I was curious about what this process would look like for someone who didn't have an early emergency.
So I asked Jay Reinstein, who works with Alzheimer's Society as a national early stage consultant. Last year, after working problems – forgetting the names of the section, trying to answer questions in meetings – he called his friend a neurologist at Duke. Early, he was diagnosed with mild cognitive impairment, and then, in the same year, with Alzheimers who were starting younger.
“I didn't know anything about wills,” said Reinstein, who is 58 years old and lives in North Carolina with his wife. But it took immediate steps for himself. He told his steward, he worked with him to plan for him to stay in the office for another six months to complete his final projects. He was able to take all his sick leave at the end of his period, enabling him to earn a salary for a longer period.
During that time, he transferred his power of attorney to his wife, and he organized his government pension so that he would go to her after he had gone over. He and his wife also decided that he would prefer a 24/7 in-house nurse, rather than going into a nursing home; They budget $ 20,000 per month, which they were able to save through their retirement savings.
Reinstein's case is the textbook model for early planning – especially with many resources, monetary and other, which he recognizes as a unique privilege. But he was anxious by phone with me. He wants to know what his life will look like, and his neurologist doesn't have answers. Dementia is as unique as the person who influences it: it may still be able to volunteer as activists with the Alzheimer's Society; Maybe his tours will be limited to lunch or movies with friends.
It just sucks.
When it comes to dementia, there is so much that you can't plan. And when carers need to act quickly – like my family, and Tomás – their ability to jump in depends very much on their privilege. In many ways, the lucky people are: My parents are very educated, and they had lots of resources to look after my grandfather. Tom's families were able to refocus their living arrangements to care for his father, and in the field of medicine, Tom had additional background information that facilitated the transition.
Still, it's never easy. As well as how to care for her father, my mom worked full-time as an executive, attracting me, a 7-year-old woman, and always dealing with a complex pregnancy that brought her to the emergency room. After giving birth to my brother, she was looking after an infant. “Every day, I'm just waking up and thinking, Who will be disappointed today?”She told me.
Tom's early retirement requires them to enter his mother's retirement savings to cover some of the health care costs. And while Tom was able to find a new job, he still had to spend time away from Hannah, his now blessed friend and friends.
“There's just sucks,” said Tom. When I spoke to my mother about caring for Grandpa John, she said exactly the same thing.
At present, Tom's father keeps as busy as possible. He spends much of his hours arranging things around the house, and spending time with his wife and grandchildren. He and Tom keep text about sports, and keeps his family in touch to ensure that they are all aware of his doctor's appointments. Earlier this month, Tom's brother took his father back to get his MRI results: As with all the other tests, they were inconclusive.
In upholding neuroscience, I would like to believe that it can eliminate uncertainty. It is certain that all the progress made over the past twenty years has made Tom and his family a clear idea of what was wrong, and in some way ahead.
But it made me realize that I had over-evaluated the ability of science to solve personal problems. During a conversation with Tom over the phone while I was in Austin and he was at home in Virginia, I made a frank offer of lifestyle modifications – such as avoiding smoking and drinking, socializing, exercise, and diet. get healthy – the most significant risks – reduced interventions to be done by dementia research.
My words felt weak. Sure, anyone can go for a walk around the block, and maybe that's enough to keep it worse. However, it is not a long-term game plan. Without his father's short-term memory, he is a normal part of his family's life.
“No one would ever be prepared for that,” said Tom. Even its background, and morbidity and mortality statistics around it in the pharmaceutical world, there was not enough to prepare himself and his family for an emergency of this kind.
Science can provide answers and protocols one day for people developing dementia. But these are years. People today do not have time to make wounds and hawks. They must make decisions now, and they probably won't be perfect. But at least Tom and his family are doing together.