41 Worst Movies That Should Have Never Existed
“Joker 2” Receives Criticism for Musical Format and narrative Choices
Table of Contents
Disappointment with the Musical Genre
Early reactions to “Joker 2” have focused on disappointment with its shift to a musical format.Several Reddit users expressed dismay upon learning the sequel would include musical numbers, with one user stating they “lost hope when I read ‘musical'” [Reddit – in/fostmaker].
The film is specifically categorized as a “jukebox musical,” meaning it primarily features pre-existing songs from popular artists rather than original compositions for the movie [Reddit – u/SchoolClassic]. According to the film’s soundtrack facts on Wikipedia, Lady Gaga wrote only one original song for the film [Reddit – u/SchoolClassic].
Narrative Concerns and Lack of Action
Beyond the musical aspect, some viewers found the narrative of “Joker 2” to be problematic. One commenter noted the film seemed preoccupied with making the audience feel regret for enjoying the first “Joker” movie, spending significant time depicting Joker’s remorse [Reddit – u/dickgivins].
A key criticism was the perceived lack of significant events or consequences within the plot. One user reported that “no one dies in the movie” (with a brief exception near the end) and that Joker himself does not commit any killings [Reddit – u/Dickgivins]. This led to a feeling of the film being “intensely dull” and lacking substantial action.
Mixed Reactions to Musical Segments
Despite the overall negative sentiment, reactions to the musical segments themselves were not universally negative. One commenter admitted to actually enjoying some of those portions of the film, despite broader issues with the sequel [Reddit – u/Dickgivins].
