The path to professional hockey isn’t always linear and for goaltender Emmett Croteau, it’s been a journey marked by strategic decisions and a willingness to embrace opportunity. After utilizing the NCAA transfer portal, the Montreal Canadiens prospect is finding his stride at Dartmouth College, showcasing the potential that prompted the Canadiens to select him in the sixth round of the 2022 NHL Draft.
Croteau’s hockey background includes a stint with St. John Bosco High School in Virginia during the 2019-20 season. He then returned to Canada and spent time in the USHL with the Waterloo Black Hawks, where he posted a .917 save percentage in six postseason games during the 2021-22 season. That performance caught the eye of Montreal, who drafted him 162nd overall.
However, the jump to NCAA hockey wasn’t immediate. Croteau initially committed to Clarkson University, but saw limited action, appearing in only six games last season. Recognizing the need for more playing time to continue his development, he entered the transfer portal – a move that has proven beneficial.
This season with Dartmouth, Croteau has a 3-1 record and a .917 save percentage as of December 20, 2024, according to reports. His performance has been a key factor in Dartmouth’s surprising success, establishing them as a team to watch in the ECAC Hockey conference. The team’s strong start has been noted as a significant development in the Ivy League’s resurgence in NCAA hockey.
At 6’4” and 209 lbs, Croteau possesses the size NHL teams covet in a goaltender. Scouts have noted his ability to fill the net and his quick movements post-to-post. His leg extension and glove work are also considered strengths, demonstrating a proactive style that anticipates rebounds and prevents scoring opportunities. He’s described as a “fast crab” moving laterally, a testament to his agility for a larger goaltender.
Despite his progress, Croteau is still relatively early in his development. At 22 years old (born December 7, 2003), he’s gaining valuable experience in college hockey, which is crucial for his long-term prospects. He’s currently in his second year of collegiate play, and the opportunity to compete for a starting role next season could be pivotal. If that opportunity doesn’t materialize, the transfer portal remains an option, allowing him to find a program where he can consistently see game action.
The Canadiens are taking a patient approach with Croteau, recognizing that he needs time to refine his skills and gain confidence. He is currently projected to be 1-2 years away from playing in the AHL with the Laval Rocket, Montreal’s affiliate team. The organization isn’t rushing his development, understanding that a well-rounded goaltender takes time to cultivate.
Croteau’s journey highlights the increasing importance of the transfer portal for college athletes, particularly in situations where playing time is limited. It allows players to proactively manage their development and find environments where they can maximize their potential. For Croteau, it’s been a game-changer, providing him with the opportunity to showcase his abilities and move closer to his goal of becoming an NHL backup.
Adding to his unique background, Croteau has Metis (aboriginal) status in Canada, classifying him as a non-import player in USA Hockey. He also has a brother, Carson Croteau, who also plays hockey.
As Dartmouth continues its season, all eyes will be on Croteau. His performance will not only impact the team’s success but also shape his future within the Canadiens organization. The ECAC semifinals in March 2025 saw four teams vying for a single NCAA spot, demonstrating the competitive landscape Croteau is navigating. His continued development will be a key storyline to watch as he progresses towards his NHL aspirations.
