Action Comics #1075 Review: Superman’s Phantom Zone Adventure

Action Comics #1075 Review: Superman’s Phantom Zone Adventure

November 14, 2024 Catherine Williams Entertainment

Action Comics #1075

Release Information

  • Scheduled Arrival: November 13, 2024
  • Cover Date: January 2025

Cover Artists:

  • Clayton Henry
  • Tomeu Morey

Variant Covers:

  • Sebastian Fiumara
  • Lucio Parrillo
  • Ibrahim Moustafa
  • Kieron Grant
  • Steve Beach
  • Meghan Hetrick

Reviewed by: Marc Lax

Main Story: “Phantoms – Part Six”

  • Writer: Mark Waid
  • Artists: Clayton Henry, Michael Shelfer

Superman, Jor-El, and Lara face a council regarding Jor-El’s use of the Phantom Zone projector. After a tense meeting, they leave but learn that Jor-El plans to use a stolen wristband to aid Superman. Meanwhile, Aethyer’s anger grows, threatening Earth with immense power.

Story Rating: 4/5
Comments: The story provokes thoughts about the true nature of Jor-El versus Superman’s perception. Lara is portrayed as a powerful ally. However, the subplot with Conner and Keenan feels out of place.

Art Rating: 5/5
Comments: The artwork by Henry and Shelfer is stunning, effectively depicting Krypton and the Phantom Zone.

Backup Story: “Supergirl – Who Are You?”

  • Writer: Mariko Tamaki
  • Artist: Skylar Patridge

Supergirl teams up with the prisoner and a robot to escape from shark aliens. The prisoner is revealed to have destructive powers.

Story Rating: 2/5
Comments: The narrative lacks excitement, and the characters fail to engage the reader.

Art Rating: 3/5
Comments: The art is adequate but doesn’t elevate the story.

Short Story: “Memory Lane”

  • Writer: Joshua Williamson
  • Artist: John Bogdanove

Perry White reflects on his past and his journey to becoming mayor of Metropolis. The next day, he celebrates his victory.

Story Rating: 4/5
Comments: This nostalgia-driven story provides a heartfelt moment for Perry White.

Art Rating: 4/5
Comments: Bogdanove’s art captures the essence of the story well.

Cover Art Rating: 4/5
Comments: A strong cover that highlights key moments in Superman’s history.

Variant Cover Ratings:

  • 4/5: Patriotic Superman
  • 4/5: Lex Luthor with Kryptonite
  • 4/5: Superman over Kent farm
  • 4/5: Superman breaking chains
  • 4/5: Superman and Lois with fireworks
  • 2/5: Colorful yet unclear Superman image

For more insights, check out the Mild Mannered Reviews contents page.