After Federal Elections, Albertans Mobilize for Canada Separation
- EDMONTON - Once a self-described Canadian nationalist, Katheryn Speck says she traveled the world with a maple leaf on her backpack and lived in Quebec to become bilingual.
- Hannah Henze stated that she believes a government led by Pierre Hairy would offer more hope for Alberta than another Liberal mandate, which she fears would harm the...
- Leo Jensen expressed concern that Canadians are worried about potential job losses in the automotive industry due to U.S.
Alberta Separatist Rally Draws Supporters, Counter-protesters in edmonton
EDMONTON – Once a self-described Canadian nationalist, Katheryn Speck says she traveled the world with a maple leaf on her backpack and lived in Quebec to become bilingual.
Posted at 8:55 p.m.
Photo Jason franson, Canadian Press
People gather to support the idea that Alberta becomes a 51e state during a rally in the Edmonton Legislative Assembly on Saturday May 3, 2025.
Hannah Henze stated that she believes a government led by Pierre Hairy would offer more hope for Alberta than another Liberal mandate, which she fears would harm the country.
Leo Jensen expressed concern that Canadians are worried about potential job losses in the automotive industry due to U.S. tariffs, but seem less concerned about protecting jobs in Alberta’s oil and gas sector.
Jensen also criticized what he sees as hypocrisy,stating,”I do not see how a province like Quebec can appropriate all our dirty money,but it will not leave a dirty pipeline crossing Quebec to finance an oil refinery in New Brunswick.”
A small group of counter-demonstrators attempted to disrupt the rally, holding signs that claimed separation would violate treaties with First Nations.
Photo Jason Franson, Canadian press
This week, the government of Prime Minister Danielle Smith proposed a bill to lower the criteria for the holding of a referendum.
Piikani Nation Chief Troy Knowlton stated in a letter earlier this week that while frustration in Western Canada over the Federal Liberal Party is understandable,Alberta cannot interfere with or deny existing treaties.
During her provincial radio program on Saturday, Premier Danielle Smith affirmed that she fully respects treaty rights.
“everything I do changes the relationship of Alberta with Ottawa.first Nations have their own relationship with Ottawa, and it is inscribed in the treaties. That does not change,”
Danielle Smith, premier of Alberta
Smith had previously threatened a “national unity crisis” if her demands were not met by the next Prime Minister within six months, but this week reiterated her support for a sovereign Alberta within a united Canada.
Susan Westernaier, a rally participant, expressed her belief that Alberta would be better off separated.
“We have oil, we have the resources. everything is fine,” she said, also claiming that Monday’s election was rigged.
Alberta Separatism: A Q&A on the Edmonton Rally
This article provides facts about a recent rally in Edmonton regarding Alberta’s potential separation from Canada. The content is based solely on the provided text.
What was the main focus of the Alberta rally in Edmonton?
the rally in Edmonton centered around the idea of Alberta becoming a separate entity, potentially even the 51st state of the United States. Several individuals expressed their views on the matter.
Who attended the rally?
the rally drew both supporters of Alberta separatism and counter-protesters. The article mentions the following individuals, but attendance numbers are not given:
- Katheryn Speck
- Hannah Henze
- Leo Jensen
- Susan Westernaier
What were the main arguments in favor of Alberta separation?
Those in favor of separation expressed several key points:
- Resource Wealth: Susan Westernaier stated, “We have oil, we have the resources.Everything is fine.” The underlying argument is that Alberta’s resources could make it economically viable as an independent entity.
- Discontent with federal Government: Some participants, like Hannah Henze, believe that a different federal government (led by Pierre Hairy) would offer more hope for Alberta, suggesting that the current federal policies are viewed negatively.
- Perceived Hypocrisy: Leo Jensen criticized what he sees as hypocrisy regarding the treatment of Alberta’s oil and gas industry compared to other provinces like Quebec.
Were there any counter-protests at the rally?
Yes, a small group of counter-demonstrators attended the rally. They held signs arguing that separation would violate treaties with First Nations.
What is the position of the Alberta government on separation?
The article indicates that Premier Danielle Smith supports a sovereign Alberta within a united Canada. While she respects treaty rights, her actions aim to change the relationship between Alberta and Ottawa.
“everything I do changes the relationship of Alberta with Ottawa.first Nations have their own relationship with Ottawa, and it is inscribed in the treaties. That does not change,”
danielle Smith, premier of Alberta
Her government also proposed a bill to lower the criteria for holding a referendum, which could be seen as a step towards greater provincial autonomy.
What are some of the key concerns related to Alberta separation?
While the article highlights some arguments in favor of separation, it also touches on concerns:
- Treaty Rights: counter-protesters emphasized that separation could violate treaties with First Nations.
- Economic Impact: The article mentions potential job losses in the automotive industry due to U.S.tariffs, which might influence opinions on economic stability. The potential impact on Alberta’s oil and gas sector is also a consideration.
- National Unity: The Premier previously threatened a “national unity crisis” if demands were not met by the Federal Government.
What are some of the opinions expressed at the rally?
People expressed varied opinions at the rally, with the source material providing some specific examples:
- Katheryn Speck once considered herself a Canadian nationalist.
- Hannah Henze believes a government led by Pierre Hairy would offer Alberta more hope.
- Leo Jensen expressed concern about the focus on protecting jobs in the automotive industry while potentially neglecting Alberta’s oil and gas sector.
- susan Westernaier believes Alberta would be better off separated.
Summary of Key Issues
Here’s a summary table outlining key issues discussed in the provided article:
| Issue | Description | Key Perspectives |
|---|---|---|
| Alberta Separatism | The idea of Alberta becoming independent from Canada. |
|
| Economic Concerns | Discussions around job losses and resource management. |
|
| Political Climate | Frustration with the Federal Liberal Party and potential party leadership change. |
|
