Ahmad Dhani Ignores Komnas Perempuan, Sticks to Naturalization Ideology
Ahmad Dhani’s Naturalization Idea Sparks Controversy
Table of Contents
- Ahmad Dhani’s Naturalization Idea Sparks Controversy
- Ahmad Dhani’s Controversial Naturalization Proposal: A Q&A
- What is Ahmad Dhani’s naturalization idea?
- Why is Ahmad Dhani’s naturalization idea controversial?
- How does Ahmad Dhani defend his naturalization stance?
- What is naturalization in the context of sports?
- What is Komnas Perempuan’s stance on Ahmad Dhani’s proposal?
- What are the ethical concerns raised by Ahmad Dhani’s proposal?
- What laws might ahmad Dhani’s statement violate?
- Has Ahmad Dhani been summoned regarding this issue?
- What is “genetic development” in the context of Ahmad Dhani’s argument?
- Key Figures and Organizations Involved
Jakarta – On March 12, 2025, Ahmad Dhani, a member of Commission X of the DPR from the Gerindra faction, responded to criticism from Komnas Perempuan (National Commission on Violence Against Women) regarding his idea of naturalizing older foreign football players and marrying them to Indonesian women. Dhani maintains that his idea is not wrong.
Dhani Defends His Naturalization Stance
Ahmad Dhani addressed the press on Wednesday, stating, Saya tidak melihat ada yang salah dalam pernyataan (pemikiran) saya,
which translates to “I don’t see anything wrong with my statement (thought).”
Dhani believes that many do not understand his statements regarding racism. The Dewa 19 band member suggested that those “shouting racism” should educate themselves first.
Understanding Naturalization
Naturalization is the process by which foreign citizens can become citizens of a country. In sports, it often involves granting citizenship to foreign athletes to allow them to represent the country in international competitions.
He firmly stands by his opinion on naturalization, emphasizing genetic advancement. Banyak orang tidak paham apa itu rasis. Termasuk yang ‘teriak rasis’. Mereka lebih baik belajar dulu apa itu rasism,
he stated, meaning, “Many people don’t understand what racism is. Including those ’shouting racism’. They better learn what racism is first.”
Focus on genetic Development
Dhani remains committed to his idea: Dan saya tetap dalam usaha saya menjodohkan janda-janda di seluruh Nusantara untuk dijodohkan dengan bibit unggul pemain bola di Asia maupun Eropa tanpa peduli apa pendapat Komnas Perempuan,
which means,”And I am still trying to match widows throughout the archipelago with superior football players from Asia and Europe,nonetheless of what Komnas Perempuan thinks.”
He added, Ini dalam dunia sains disebut genetic development,
or “This is called *genetic development* in the world of science.”
MKD Summons and dhani’s Response
in response to the DPR’s Honorary Council (MKD) summoning him the following week,Dhani stated he is “1,000 percent ready” to clarify his statements.Siap 1.000 persen,
he affirmed.
Komnas perempuan’s Criticism
Komnas Perempuan previously condemned Ahmad Dhani’s statements on naturalization, deeming them sexist. They believe Dhani is demeaning women by suggesting they are merely reproductive machines.
Dengan beralibi ‘out of the box‘ dan intonasi bercanda, AD mengusulkan agar naturalisasi diperluas bagi pemain bola ‘di atas 40 tahun… dan mungkin yang duda’ untuk dinikahkan dengan perempuan agar menghasilkan keturunan ‘Indonesian born’ yang dinilainya akan bisa memiliki kualitas keterampilan sepakbola yang lebih baik.
Ketua Komnas Perempuan Andy yentriyani, March 12, 2025
This translates to: “Under the guise of ‘thinking out of the box’ and in a joking tone, AD suggested that naturalization be extended to football players ‘over 40… and perhaps widowers’ to be married to women in order to produce ‘Indonesian born’ offspring who he believes will have better football skills.”
Komnas Perempuan further stated:
Pernyataan AD dinilai melecehkan karena menempatkan perempuan sekadar mesin reproduksi anak, pelayan seksual suami. Apalagi pernyataan ini dilanjutkan dengan menyebutkan bahwa jika pemain sepakbola yang dinaturalisasi itu beragama Islam, maka bisa dinikahkan dengan empat perempuan.
Ketua Komnas Perempuan Andy Yentriyani, March 12, 2025
Meaning: “AD’s statement is considered demeaning because it places women merely as reproductive machines, sexual servants of their husbands. Moreover, this statement is followed by mentioning that if the naturalized football player is Muslim, he can be married to four women.”
They argue that Ahmad Dhani’s statements exploit women and degrade the nation with what they consider racist remarks.
Ethical Considerations and Legal Framework
Komnas Perempuan reminded members of the DPR RI of their mandate to uphold the 4 pillars of Nationhood and practice them in daily life. They should uphold values, including respect for women as equal human beings, not merely sexual and reproductive objects.
Pernyataan bersifat seksis ini juga bertentangan dengan komitmen Indonesia untuk kesetaraan dan keadilan gender sebagaimana termaktub dalam UU No 7 Tahun 1984,
stated Komnas HAM,meaning,”This sexist statement also contradicts Indonesia’s commitment to gender equality and justice as stipulated in Law No. 7 of 1984.”
Furthermore, Pernyataan AD berpotensi melanggar hak asasi perempuan, mencederai citra, kehormatan, dan kewibawaan DPR RI, khususnya Komisi X, yang juga mengawal bidang pendidikan,
which translates to: “AD’s statement perhaps violates women’s human rights, damages the image, honor, and authority of the DPR RI, especially Commission X, which also oversees education.”
Key Points of Contention
- Naturalization: The process of granting citizenship to foreign football players.
- Genetic Development: Dhani’s focus on improving the national team through strategic marriages.
- Komnas Perempuan’s Concerns: allegations of sexism and exploitation of women.
Ahmad Dhani’s Controversial Naturalization Proposal: A Q&A
This article explores the controversy surrounding Ahmad Dhani’s proposal to naturalize older foreign football players and marry them to Indonesian women, examining the ethical considerations, legal framework, and key arguments from all sides.
What is Ahmad Dhani’s naturalization idea?
Ahmad Dhani, a member of Commission X of the DPR from the Gerindra faction, proposed naturalizing foreign football players over 40, potentially widowers, and marrying them to Indonesian women. He believes this would produce “Indonesian born” offspring with superior football skills.
Why is Ahmad Dhani’s naturalization idea controversial?
The idea has been widely criticized,especially by Komnas Perempuan (National Commission on Violence Against Women),who view it as sexist and demeaning to women. Critics argue that it treats women as mere reproductive machines and sexual servants, and that it promotes racist ideas.
How does Ahmad Dhani defend his naturalization stance?
Dhani defends his proposal by stating that he sees nothing wrong with it. He believes his idea focuses on genetic growth and suggests that those who accuse him of racism should educate themselves on the topic. he maintains that he will pursue matching widows with superior football players regardless of Komnas Perempuan’s opinion.
What is naturalization in the context of sports?
Naturalization in sports refers to the process of granting citizenship to foreign athletes, allowing them to represent a country in international competitions. This is often done to improve a nation’s sports team.
What is Komnas Perempuan’s stance on Ahmad Dhani’s proposal?
Komnas Perempuan strongly condemns Ahmad Dhani’s statements, viewing them as sexist and exploitative. They argue that the proposal reduces women to reproductive objects and sexual servants. They also highlighted that if the naturalized player is Muslim, the statement implies to marry four wives is demeaning.
What are the ethical concerns raised by Ahmad Dhani’s proposal?
Critics argue that Ahmad dhani’s proposal raises ethical concerns related to:
Sexism: Treating women as a means to an end (producing offspring with desired traits).
Exploitation: Potentially exploiting both foreign players and Indonesian women.
Racism: Implies the superiority of certain genetic lines.
What laws might ahmad Dhani’s statement violate?
Komnas Perempuan asserts that Ahmad Dhani’s statements potentially violate:
Law No. 7 of 1984: This law reflects Indonesia’s commitment to gender equality and justice.
* women’s Human Rights: The statements could be interpreted as infringing upon women’s rights and dignity.
Has Ahmad Dhani been summoned regarding this issue?
Yes, the DPR’s Honorary Council (MKD) summoned Ahmad Dhani to clarify his statements. Dhani stated he is ready to do so.
What is “genetic development” in the context of Ahmad Dhani’s argument?
Ahmad Dhani uses the term “genetic development” to justify his proposal. He believes that by strategically matching Indonesian widows with “superior” foreign football players, he can improve the genetic makeup of future Indonesian footballers.
Key Figures and Organizations Involved
| Figure/Association | Role | Stance |
| :————————– | :—————————————————————— | :———————————————————————————————- |
| Ahmad Dhani | Member of commission X of the DPR from the Gerindra faction | Proponent of the naturalization and strategic marriage proposal. |
| Komnas Perempuan | National Commission on Violence Against Women | Strongly opposes the proposal, viewing it as sexist and exploitative. |
| Andy Yentriyani | Ketua (Chairwoman) of Komnas Perempuan | Vocal critic of Ahmad Dhani’s statements. |
| DPR’s Honorary Council (MKD) | Investigates ethical violations by members of the DPR | Summoned Ahmad Dhani to clarify his statements. |