Apple vs. Fintiv: Apple Pay Lawsuit Delay
Apple Wins Again: Fintiv Drops Apple Pay Patent Case, Files New Lawsuit
Table of Contents
After over seven years of legal battles, Fintiv has voluntarily dismissed its patent infringement claims against Apple regarding Apple Pay. This dismissal comes just days after a Texas judge once again ruled in Apple’s favor, finding no infringement on Fintiv’s patents. However, the story doesn’t end there. Fintiv has now filed a new lawsuit in Georgia, alleging trade secret theft and racketeering.Here’s a breakdown of the long-running dispute and what this latest growth means.
A Long and Winding Legal Road
Fintiv first sued Apple in December 2018,claiming Apple Pay infringed on its patents related to mobile payment technology.The case has been fraught with delays,legal maneuvers,and repeated rulings against Fintiv.
Here’s a timeline of key events:
December 2018: Fintiv sues Apple in Texas, alleging apple Pay infringes its patent.
September 2020: Judge Albright rejects Fintiv’s attempt to add willful infringement claims.
June 2022: Fintiv delays trial with a last-minute “emergency” motion.
June 2023: Judge Albright grants Apple summary judgment of noninfringement. May 2025: Federal Circuit remands case for further review on certain claims.
July 30, 2025: Judge Albright again rules Apple does not infringe most claims.
August 2,2025: Fintiv voluntarily dismisses its remaining claims after jury selection.
August 7, 2025: Fintiv files new Georgia lawsuit alleging trade secret theft and racketeering.
Apple responded to the dismissal of the Texas case with a statement shared with 9to5Mac:
“The court has repeatedly rejected Fintiv’s claims and we believe this latest attempt to distract from their failed patent case should also be dismissed. We launched Apple Pay over a decade ago and have been innovating every day sence to give users the best, most private and secure experiance available. we’ll continue to defend against these false claims.”
The Numbers Tell the Story
Fintiv’s litigation record paints a clear picture. The company has spent over seven years pursuing legal action against Apple, but has yet to achieve a single victory.
Here’s a look at the key statistics:
7+ years: Time Fintiv has spent suing Apple over Apple pay
2: Times Judge Albright ruled Apple does not infringe the patent
0: Trials Fintiv has won against Apple
5: Fintiv patents invalidated in PayPal litigation (4 in court, 1 at the USPTO)
$9 million: Debt Fintiv is accused of defaulting on in a separate breach-of-contract case
1 week: Time between abandoning Texas trial and filing new Georgia lawsuit
The fast pivot to a new lawsuit in georgia raises eyebrows, especially considering the consistent setbacks in the Texas case.
What’s Next: Trade Secret Theft and Racketeering Claims
Fintiv’s new lawsuit,filed in Georgia,dramatically shifts the focus.Instead of patent infringement, the company is now alleging trade secret theft and racketeering. Details of the lawsuit are still emerging, but these are serious accusations.
Racketeering claims, in particular, suggest Fintiv believes Apple engaged in a pattern of criminal activity. It remains to be seen what evidence Fintiv will present to support these claims.This new legal battle will undoubtedly be closely watched, and could considerably escalate the conflict between the two companies.
Why This Matters to you
While this legal drama might seem distant, it highlights the importance of innovation and intellectual property rights. Apple’s continued defence of its technology ensures that you, as a user, benefit from ongoing advancements in secure and private payment options like Apple Pay.The outcome of these cases could influence the future of mobile payment technology and the protection of innovative ideas.