Liverpool’s season continues to oscillate between moments of promise and frustrating collapse, a pattern that is increasingly fueling questions about Arne Slot’s future at Anfield. The latest low point – a stunning 3-0 defeat at home to Nottingham Forest – has amplified the scrutiny, with even those who initially backed the Dutch manager beginning to express doubts. While Slot has publicly defended a former member of his coaching staff, the broader narrative surrounding the club is one of growing unease.
The defeat to Forest, as reported by The Athletic, wasn’t merely a loss; it was a demonstration of Liverpool’s current vulnerabilities. The team appeared listless and devoid of ideas, a stark contrast to the high-energy performances that characterized their title-winning campaign last season. Slot himself acknowledged the team’s struggles, stating, “We hardly gave a chance away but the ball kept going in for the opposition,” a sentiment that underscores the frustrating nature of their recent form.
This downturn has inevitably led to external criticism, most notably from former Manchester United striker Wayne Rooney. Rooney, speaking on The Overlap Fan Debate, suggested that Slot lacks the “aura” possessed by previous Liverpool managers, particularly Jurgen Klopp. “I have met him a couple of times, but I just don’t think, for Liverpool, he has that aura – and maybe that’s because Liverpool have just come off the back of Jurgen Klopp as manager – it’s difficult for anyone to do that but I just don’t think there is that aura about him,” Rooney said, a comment that quickly gained traction and intensified the debate surrounding Slot’s position.
The irony of the situation is not lost on observers. Slot arrived at Liverpool in June 2024 with a reputation for tactical acumen and a proven track record, culminating in a Premier League title in his first season. Yet, less than two years later, he finds himself facing questions about his long-term suitability for the role. As Liverpool.com noted, this contradiction is a familiar one at elite clubs, where sustained success demands more than just silverware; it requires a consistent level of performance and a clear sense of direction.
Adding another layer to the complexity is Slot’s recent defense of Aaron Briggs, the Liverpool set-piece coach who was sacked in December. Despite a noticeable improvement in Liverpool’s set-piece threat following Briggs’ departure, Slot has publicly stated it is “very unfair” to blame the coach for previous struggles. This defense, as highlighted by This Is Anfield, has been met with mixed reactions, with some interpreting it as a sign of loyalty while others view it as a stubborn refusal to acknowledge tactical shortcomings. Slot elaborated on the improvements in a press conference, pointing to fitness and set-piece work as key factors, but the timing of his defense of Briggs, amidst the team’s broader struggles, is notable.
The improvement in set-piece performance since Briggs’ dismissal is a demonstrable fact. Soccernews.com reported that Liverpool’s ability to capitalize on set-piece opportunities has increased significantly, contributing to a more potent attacking threat. However, this improvement hasn’t translated into consistent results, as evidenced by the defeat to Nottingham Forest.
The situation is further complicated by the high expectations at Anfield. Liverpool is a club steeped in history and tradition, and fans demand a level of performance that reflects that legacy. Rooney’s comments tapped into this sentiment, suggesting that Slot may not possess the intangible qualities necessary to command the respect and loyalty of the Anfield faithful. This echoes long-standing traditions at the club, where a manager’s personality and presence are often considered as important as their tactical abilities.
Peter Crouch, speaking to Facebook groups, believes that Liverpool are “not that kind of club” to sack a manager quickly, even in the face of adversity. This suggests a degree of patience within the ownership, but also implies that Slot needs to demonstrate a clear plan for improvement to avoid further scrutiny. The club’s decision-making will likely be influenced by their Champions League qualification prospects, which currently appear uncertain.
The question now is whether Slot can turn things around. He faces a significant challenge in restoring confidence to the team and convincing the fans that he is the right man to lead Liverpool forward. The upcoming fixtures will be crucial, and any further setbacks could intensify the pressure and raise the possibility of a managerial change. The club’s hierarchy will be closely monitoring the situation, weighing the potential benefits of sticking with Slot against the risks of allowing the team’s struggles to continue. The coming weeks will undoubtedly be pivotal in determining the future of Arne Slot at Liverpool.
