Black Death’s Lingering shadow: How Early Life Hardship Shaped Survivors’ Health
Table of Contents
The Black Death, a devastating pandemic that swept across Europe in the mid-14th century, offers a unique window into the long-term effects of nutritional stress on human health. While mortality rates varied dramatically across regions, with some areas losing up too 75% of their population, researchers are exploring how the experiences of survivors, notably those who faced hardship in infancy and childhood, might have shaped their health in the long run.
Environment Matters: Unlocking Secrets in Teeth
Sharon dewitte,a bioarchaeologist,and her colleagues are delving into this complex question by examining the isotopic signatures preserved in the teeth of individuals who lived between 1100 and 1540 AD. As DeWitte explains, the food consumed during infancy and childhood leaves an indelible mark on tooth dentine, subtly altering the types of carbon and nitrogen atoms present. Crucially, periods of extreme nutritional stress cause the body to break down its own fat and muscle stores, which possess a distinct isotopic signature compared to ingested food.
The Black Death as a natural Experiment
The Black Death, also known as the second pandemic of plague, serves as an “ideal laboratory” for studying these phenomena. The stark differences in mortality rates across Europe-ranging from approximately 30% in parts of England to a staggering 75% in florence, Italy-raise critical questions about why some populations fared worse than others.
To investigate these disparities, DeWitte’s team analyzed the isotopes in the teeth of hundreds of individuals exhumed from English cemeteries dating from 1100 to 1540 AD. This included samples from the East Smithfield Black Death Cemetery in London, established in 1348, where hundreds of plague victims were interred in mass graves.
While DeWitte acknowledges that the findings are preliminary, given the limited historical records available for many of the individuals studied, the research offers intriguing insights. The data suggests that malnutrition experienced in early life may have had a profound, albeit context-dependent, impact on adult health.
Adaptation and Mismatch: The Double-Edged Sword of Scarcity
when infants and children endure periods of food scarcity, their bodies may adapt in ways that prepare them for future hardship. These adaptations can include altered metabolism, enabling more efficient use of scarce calories.Such changes can be advantageous in environments of chronic scarcity.
Though, DeWitte posits that these adaptations could become detrimental when the environment shifts towards abundance. Evidence suggests that in the aftermath of the Black Death,surviving laborers in england experienced improved conditions,with demands for higher wages leading to greater access to resources.
“People who experienced nutritional stress as children may have had a mismatch with their environments later in life,” DeWitte stated. “If there’s now a resource abundance, but their bodies were shaped for an environment of scarcity, they may have poor health outcomes, like packing too many fat stores, which can lead to cardiovascular disease.”
This research underscores DeWitte’s long-standing fascination with understanding why some individuals within the same society enjoy good health while others do not. By studying the skeletal remains of those who lived through the Black Death, scientists are gaining a deeper appreciation for the enduring legacy of early life experiences on human health across centuries.
co-authors of the new research include Julia Beaumont and Jacqueline Towers at the University of Bradford in the United Kingdom; Brittany Walter of the Defence POW/MIA Accounting Agency; and emily Brennan at the University of South Carolina.
