Cody Rhodes All In Celebrity Interest: Initial Misunderstanding
When the “Slow Dancing” Crowd Goes Wild: Cody Rhodes recalls John Mayer’s Unexpected “All In”
CHICAGO – In the ever-blurring world where celebrity meets squared circle, few stories are as delightfully unexpected as the one Cody Rhodes tells about John Mayer and the original “All In” wrestling event. Before AEW became a household name, before “The American Nightmare” returned to WWE, there was “All In” – a self-funded, independent wrestling show that captured the imagination of fans worldwide. And apparently, the imagination of a certain Grammy-winning musician as well.
Cody and Brandi Rhodes recently reminisced about the experience, revealing that the initial contact from Mayer’s camp felt like a prank. “I get an email,3 a.m., from John Mayer’s manager,” Cody explained. “There’s a bachelor party. They want to attend All In – the original All In - which has been very, very sold out.”
Understandably, Rhodes was skeptical. “At that point, I just thought it was a rib.A good wrestling rib.” It wasn’t until the morning, when he was confronted by someone asking if he had denied John mayer tickets, that the reality began to sink in.
The story highlights the growing crossover appeal of professional wrestling, where mainstream celebrities are increasingly drawn to the unique blend of athleticism, storytelling, and raw emotion. We’ve seen it in WWE with figures like Logan Paul, Jelly Roll, and Travis Scott, but Mayer’s interest in “All In” felt different, more organic.
Rhodes, ever the gracious host, ensured Mayer and his party had a prime viewing spot. “Middle of the aisle,” he recalled, providing a buffer from the more boisterous elements of the crowd.During his match with Nick Aldis, Rhodes even managed to catch a glimpse of Mayer in the audience.
“That was a realy fun get!” Rhodes concluded, adding that he took photos with Mayer after the show. It’s a testament to the unique appeal of “All In” and the magnetic personality of Cody Rhodes that a musician known for his soft rock and blues would find himself ringside at a wrestling event. It’s a reminder that sometimes,