Concussion & CTE: Why Awareness Matters
- Concussion in sport continues to make headlines, whether it be class actions, young men flocking to the highly violent "RunIt" activity or debate about whether Australian rules football...
- Bringing this weighty issue to greater prominence are the former athletes who bravely share their long-term health struggles after careers in sport-cognitive impairments, mental health issues or concerns...
- Yet for all the progress made by many sports in recent years, it feels like we still have not fully grasped the understanding of CTE-or maybe we don't...
Credit: Pixabay/CC0 Public Domain
Concussion in sport continues to make headlines, whether it be class actions, young men flocking to the highly violent “RunIt” activity or debate about whether Australian rules football should remove the “bump” once and for all.
Bringing this weighty issue to greater prominence are the former athletes who bravely share their long-term health struggles after careers in sport-cognitive impairments, mental health issues or concerns about neurodegenerative disease, specifically chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE).
Yet for all the progress made by many sports in recent years, it feels like we still have not fully grasped the understanding of CTE-or maybe we don’t want to.
Remind me again, what is CTE?
CTE is a neurodegenerative brain disease just like dementia, motor neuron disease (MND) and Parkinson’s disease.
Expert groups agree on the links between traumatic brain injury and increased risk of Alzheimer’s disease (and othre dementias), and the growing evidence of links to MND and Parkinson’s.
People who have never had a traumatic brain injury can still regrettably suffer from these diseases. Though, while CTE is rare in the general population, those with a history of repetitive impacts to the brain are more at risk.
These impacts may not be diagnosed as brain injuries or concussions, but rather non-concussive impacts (smaller hits that do not produce signs or symptoms of concussion).
Contrary to anecdotal opinion, an athlete’s concussion history is not the crucial variable in the risk and severity of CTE.
Emerging international evidence shows the risk of developing CTE (and its severity) is linked to exposure: the age a person starts full contact sport and the length of a playing career.
The grey area of concussion, CTE and mental health
currently, CTE cannot be diagnosed in living people.
Though, in understanding the progression of the disease in those who have passed away with CTE, families have described signs and symptoms including cognitive impairments such as:
- Parkinsonism
- memory loss
- trouble with planning and organizing tasks
- impulsive behaviors
- anger and irritability
- emotional instability
- substance misuse
- suicidal thoughts/behavior.
While these signs and symptoms can overlap with those we associate with mental health, this does not necessarily mean the affected person had “mental health concerns.”
The continued awareness of men’s mental health is a good thing broadly, but it has sometimes misappropriated CTE as a mental health issue. For example,some fundraising games in the names of athletes who have died with CTE are being channeled to mental health charities and institutes confusing the wider community.
Consequently, two recent tragic stories, one from the family of deceased former AFL player Shane Tuck and the other from amanda Green, the widow of the late NRL player and coach Paul Green, needed to be told.
Their stories contradicted widely held beliefs in the media and among fans that Tuck or Green were suffering with a psychiatric disease prior to their untimely deaths. Actually, they had CTE.
An uncomfortable conversation
So, why aren’t we talking about CTE more?
The answer is, sadly, it is indeed an inconvenient truth.
Considering CTE is entirely preventable if we remove the exposure risk of repetitive hits to the head, the solution is to further modify many of our most popular sports to
