Death Penalty Verdict: Constitutional Court Delivers Landmark Ruling
2024/9/20 08:14
(Updated at 9/20 08:38)
Constitutional Court to Announce Verdict on Death Penalty Case
Wang Jinfu and 37 other death row inmates have petitioned for a constitutional review of the death penalty, arguing that it violates their constitutional rights to equality, survival, and proportionality. The oral debate at the Constitutional Court concluded on April 23, and the verdict is scheduled to be announced today at 3 pm.
The preservation and abolition of the death penalty have long been a topic of public concern, with many arguing that it is unconstitutional and inhumane. The petitioners’ legal team has argued that the death penalty deprives individuals of their right to life and human dignity, and should therefore be declared unconstitutional.
In contrast, the Ministry of Justice has argued that the death penalty does not violate the protection of the right to life, nor does it constitute torture. The Ministry has also pointed out that most countries have abolished the death penalty through legislative or constitutional amendment procedures, rather than through constitutional review.
The Constitutional Court has 15 judges, 12 of whom will hear the case. In order for the death penalty to be declared unconstitutional, more than seven justices must agree.
The Judiciary Yuan has announced that the Constitutional Court has 64 seats available for the public to observe the verdict. Those interested in attending can bring their national identity card or other valid ID card to the entrance on the first floor of the Taiwan High Court Criminal Court Building from 2:15 to 2:45 pm.
Background on the Case
Wang Jinfu and 37 other death row inmates have been petitioning for a constitutional review of the death penalty since 2023. The case has been ongoing for several months, with the oral debate concluding on April 23.
The petitioners’ legal team has argued that the death penalty is unconstitutional and inhumane, and that it should be abolished. The Ministry of Justice has argued that the death penalty is necessary for maintaining public order and safety.
What to Expect
The Constitutional Court is expected to announce its verdict on the death penalty case today at 3 pm. The verdict will be open to the public and will be live-streamed online.
If the death penalty is declared unconstitutional, it could have significant implications for the justice system in Taiwan. It could also set a precedent for other countries in the region.