Discover the Hidden Gem of City Island: A Review of The Original Crab Shanty’s Seafood Delights
- On a sunny October day, I decided to visit The Original Crab Shanty on City Island, a well-known seafood destination in the Bronx.
- From outside, The Original Crab Shanty resembles a chain restaurant, but once inside, it offers a unique charm.
- on a Sunday, I was warmly greeted by Sharon, the manager who has worked there for 46 years.
The Original Crab Shanty: A Seafood Haven on City Island
On a sunny October day, I decided to visit The Original Crab Shanty on City Island, a well-known seafood destination in the Bronx. This spot had been on my list for a while, and it promised a true seafood experience.
First Impressions
From outside, The Original Crab Shanty resembles a chain restaurant, but once inside, it offers a unique charm. The decor is colorful and somewhat quirky, and the lively crowd adds to its appeal.
As I entered around 2 p.m. on a Sunday, I was warmly greeted by Sharon, the manager who has worked there for 46 years. Her friendly demeanor made me feel welcome.
The Menu
The menu includes a wide variety of seafood options, along with other dishes. I was served a large loaf of garlic bread, a popular item among patrons. This bread was golden, warm, and satisfying. I savored the entire loaf, enjoying every bite.
Delicious Dishes
I ordered the fried calamari ($14.99) and crab-stuffed clams, known as “crabby clams” ($20.99). The calamari had a light breading, a pleasant texture, and came out quickly.
The crabby clams amazed me with their generous portions. Each clam was filled with a substantial amount of crab meat, mixed in with a rich, flavorful sauce. This dish reminded me of comforting meals from childhood, creating a feeling of nostalgia.
Future Visits
I left wishing to return for more. Next time, I plan to try snow crab legs and share the garlic bread with a friend. The restaurant’s menu features many options, including seafood pastas and non-seafood dishes like prime rib and chicken.
Final Thoughts
Sharon stated that while they might lack a scenic view or fancy tablecloths, they offer excellent food at reasonable prices. City Island remains one of New York’s hidden gems, and The Original Crab Shanty is a major reason to visit.
Quick Details:
- Address: 361 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464
- Phone: (718) 885-1810
- Hours: Daily from 11 a.m. to 11 p.m.
- Price Range: $12.99 – $138.99 depending on the dish.
Whether you are a seafood lover or looking for a unique dining experience, The Original Crab Shanty is worth the visit.