Ethics of AI in Tabletop Games: Disparities Across Crowdfunding Platforms

Generative artificial intelligence (AI) is becoming more common in tabletop games. However, a divide has emerged between consumers and creators regarding its ethical use. Three major crowdfunding platforms—BackerKit, Gamefound, and Kickstarter—handle AI differently.

A recent example is the card game Draconis 8, created by Wise Wizard Games. The Kickstarter campaign raised $120,000 from nearly 1,200 backers. CEO Rob Dougherty and lead artist Antonis Papantoniou described AI as a “collaborative tool” that helped them create many cards efficiently. They highlighted their transparency about AI use as an ethical choice.

Despite this, the use of AI in art has sparked debate. Fans expressed disappointment online, with some vowing not to buy another Wise Wizard game. Conversely, other projects using AI, like Wonders of the First and Grimcoven, have still raised significant funds on crowdfunding platforms.

Kickstarter allows projects to use generative AI, provided they disclose its use. Some projects, like Draconis 8, offer clear details, while others mention AI in their FAQs or not at all. In contrast, BackerKit does not allow content solely created by AI and enforces this rule strictly. Gamefound encourages transparency but is still considering an AI usage policy.

As AI faces social rejection, these platforms may revise their policies. Concerns exist about the sustainability of the current AI trend, implying a potential shift in how these crowdfunding sites will address generative AI in the future.