Gold Market’s⁢ Reaction to News:⁢ More Random Than Rational?

⁣ Updated June 24, 2025
‍

Despite expectations, the gold market’s recent performance⁤ highlights a⁤ disconnect between news events and price action. A study analyzing over 90,000 news‍ items related to hundreds of ‍stocks over two years found that significant⁣ stock movements were frequently enough unrelated to news. Most jumps weren’t tied to news,and most news didn’t trigger jumps.

This challenges the ‍conventional wisdom that market movements ⁢are driven by identifiable external events. Rather, markets may operate more ‍randomly than many ⁤believe.

Observers often try to link news to price changes, presuming a causal relationship. When ⁤news doesn’t fit,‍ they attempt to create a cause-and-effect structure. When they can’t, they attribute market moves to “psychology,” admitting ⁢their inability to concoct ⁤a credible story.

Even the Federal Reserve has acknowledged this disconnect. After a 3.3% drop in the Dow Jones Industrial Average in 2007, ⁢the Fed chairman said he couldn’t identify a single trigger. Similarly, a major down day in August 2015 occurred despite a lack of ⁣major U.S. economic news.

The causes of major market events like the Great Depression, the 1987 crash, and the 2010 Flash Crash remain debated. A Nobel laureate admitted⁤ that the Asian financial crisis was unforeseen ⁣and its causes remain unclear.

According to ⁤the book, The Socionomic Theory of Finance, economists struggle to explain market⁢ declines as they apply⁢ a mechanical model to finance, where⁤ it doesn’t fit.

“Observers’ job, as they see it, is simply to identify which external events caused whatever price changes occur.When news seems to coincide sensibly with market movement,⁤ they presume a causal relationship.When news doesn’t fit, they attempt to devise ⁣a cause-and-effect structure to make it fit. When they cannot even devise a plausible way to twist⁣ the news into justifying market action, they chalk up the market moves to “psychology,” which means that, despite a plethora of news and numerous inventive ways to interpret it, their imaginations aren’t prodigious enough to concoct a credible causal story.”

“Most‍ of the time it is indeed easy for observers to believe ⁤in news causality. Financial markets fluctuate constantly, and news comes out constantly, and sometimes the two elements coincide well enough to reinforce commentators’ mental bias⁤ towards mechanical cause and effect. When news and the market fail to coincide, they shrug and disregard⁢ the inconsistency. Those‍ operating⁣ under the mechanics‍ paradigm in finance‍ never seem to see⁤ or care that these glaring anomalies exist.”

“None other than the chairman of the Federal Reserve weighed in on this very topic in testimony before Congress. The morning after a one-day 3.3% swoon in the DJIA in 2007, the nations’ top banker said he coudl not identify ‘a single trigger’ that caused⁢ Tuesdays dramatic drop.”‍ This is a remarkable admission for a macroeconomic mechanist who advocates ⁤”financial engineering.” More recently, August 20, 2015 sported the biggest⁣ down ⁤day in 18 months for stock prices, yet reporters ‍admitted there was a ‘lack of major U.S. economic news’ to explain it.”

Daniel Kahneman, in Thinking Fast and Slow, suggests that overconfidence and confirmation bias ‍contribute⁢ to this flawed⁢ thinking.⁣ Peopel seek data confirming their beliefs and overestimate their understanding.

“[O]ur excessive confidence in what we believe we know,and our‍ apparent inability to acknowledge the full extent of our ignorance and uncertainty⁤ of the world⁢ we live⁢ in. We⁢ are prone⁢ to overestimate how much ⁤we understand about the world . . overconfidence is ⁤fed by the illusory certainty of hindsight.”

“Contrary to the rules of philosophers of science, ⁣who advise testing hypotheses by trying‍ to refute them, people ⁢seek data that are likely to be compatible with the beliefs they‍ currently‍ hold. The confirmatory bias [of our minds] favors uncritical acceptance of suggestions⁤ and exaggerations of the likelihood of extreme ⁤and improbable events . . . [our minds are] not prone to doubt. It suppresses ambiguity and spontaneously constructs⁣ stories that are as coherent as possible.”

Frequent repetition makes falsehoods ⁤believable, as familiarity⁢ is mistaken for truth.Minds automatically ‍seek causality and confirm existing beliefs, a “positive test strategy.”

Kahneman:⁤ “A reliable way to make people believe in falsehoods is frequent repetition, because familiarity is‍ not easily distinguishable from ‍truth. . . ‍ [E]vidence is that we are born prepared to make intentional attributions.” Simply put, our minds engage in an automatic search for causality. ⁣moreover, we also engage in a deliberate search for confirming evidence of those propositions ⁢once we hold them ‍dear. This is known as “positive test strategy.”

Francis Bacon noted that people draw everything ⁤to support adopted opinions, shutting out contrary evidence. This explains why investors dismiss anomalies, clinging to ⁣the erroneous mechanics paradigm.

Bacon: “The human understanding when it has once‍ adopted an opinion (either being the received opinion or as being agreeable to itself) draws ⁤all things⁣ else⁤ to support and agree with it.”

Daniel crosby notes that trusting common myths⁢ is human, but⁢ overcoming them leads to investment success. Benoit Mandelbrot argues that economic mechanics cannot reasonably apply to financial markets.

“From the availability ⁢of‍ the multifractal alternative, it follows that, today, economics‍ and finance must be sharply distinguished .. .”

Elliott Wave analysis,a fractal-based system,offers⁣ an ⁤alternative. Investors should be judicious about ‍media consumption when making decisions.

Despite middle East⁤ tensions, gold prices turned down near a resistance box, ⁤highlighting the limitations of news-driven analysis. The gold market topped within $2 of the target, and has as declined as was ⁤to⁢ be expected, despite the escalation of the war.

Benjamin Franklin and John Adams emphasized ⁤the importance of facts over wishes and inclinations.

“So convenient a thing it is to be a reasonable ⁢creature, since ⁢it enables one to find or to make a reason for ⁢everything one has a mind to do.”

“Geese are but Geese ‍tho’ we⁤ may think ⁤’em Swans; and Truth will be Truth tho’‍ it sometimes prove mortifying and distasteful.”

“Facts are stubborn‍ things; ⁣and whatever⁤ may be our wishes, our inclinations,⁣ or the dictates of⁤ our passion, they cannot ‍alter the state of facts and evidence.”

Investors face a choice: continue with ‍flawed methods or embrace ⁤a⁢ more accurate approach to understanding gold price movements.

What’s next

As long ⁣as the resistance box holds, ⁤a larger decline is expected, perhaps creating a ⁣buying ⁢opportunity before the final rally in the cycle that began in 2015. A drop to at least ‍the 275GLD region is anticipated for the next ⁤buying opportunity,subject to adjustments based on ‍market action.