Here’s a breakdown of the key facts from the provided text, focusing on Indonesia’s aid efforts to Gaza and the underlying issues highlighted:
Key Points:
Important Aid: Indonesia is providing substantial humanitarian aid to Gaza, including 520 bundles delivered so far, with plans for more flights from Egypt in September. Baznas (Indonesia’s National Alms Agency) has already sent Rp150 billion ($9 million) and has another Rp230 billion ($14 million) reserved, aiming for a total of Rp500 billion ($30 million). They have 700+ tons of aid stored in Egypt.
Logistical Coordination: Baznas is working with the indonesian military to deliver aid. 80 tons have been delivered by air from Jordan. The Core Problem: Dependence on approval: The central issue is that all aid delivery - whether by air drops or other means – requires “approval” from Israel (referred to as “the genocider” in the text). This is seen as deeply humiliating and undermines the humanitarian effort. The author emphasizes that what should be a straightforward act of compassion is reduced to a “priviledge.”
Impact on Dignity: This dependence strips the humanitarian action of its dignity. The aid itself is symbolically tainted by the need for permission from the occupying power.
Critique of the Two-State Solution: The author argues that Indonesia’s aid efforts, while commendable, also expose the failure of the long-held ”two-state solution” as a viable path to resolving the conflict.Indonesia has historically supported this solution, but the current situation demonstrates its ineffectiveness.
Zakat & Charitable Giving: The aid is largely funded by zakat (Islamic charitable giving) from Indonesian citizens, making the situation particularly poignant.
In essence, the article argues that while Indonesia is generously providing aid to Gaza, the fact that this aid is contingent on approval from Israel highlights the power imbalance and the ongoing oppression of Palestinians. It’s a critique not of Indonesia’s efforts, but of the system that forces such dependence.
