Islanders‌ GM Eyes Matthew Schaefer as Potential Top NHL Draft Pick

Updated June 04, 2025
⁢

The new York Islanders are leaning toward selecting a player in the 2025 NHL Draft after winning the draft lottery. General Manager Mathieu ⁤Darche indicated ⁣he’s unlikely to trade away the valuable first overall pick, focusing instead on adding a top prospect to the team’s roster. The Islanders had only the tenth-best odds to win the lottery.

Speaking at the NHL Scouting Combine, Darche‌ emphasized that while the team remains open to possibilities, he anticipates the Islanders will make the first selection. He noted the presence of several strong players available and expressed confidence in securing a player who can contribute considerably for ⁣years. The NHL draft ⁣ is scheduled for June 27‍ in Los Angeles.

Among the prospects, Darche ⁤has shown particular interest in defenseman Matthew Schaefer, who plays for Erie in the Ontario hockey League. Schaefer is ranked as the top North American ⁢skater by NHL ​Central Scouting. Darche‍ praised Schaefer’s elite defensive skills, leadership, character, and skating ability.

⁢”You’ve got to be open ‍to everything,but I’d be shocked if we’re not the one speaking first,” Darche said. “When [Commissioner] Gary [Bettman] announces the first pick, I’d be shocked if it’s not the New York Islanders.”
‍

Schaefer’s 2025 season was shortened to⁣ 17 games due to a fractured clavicle‍ sustained at the World Juniors. However, he has since recovered and is​ participating in fitness testing. Darche and the Islanders staff recently met with Schaefer, further solidifying their positive impression of his leadership qualities.

⁣”There’s a lot⁢ of good players in this draft. Some names are talked more than others,but there’s other vrey good players. ‌Matthew, obviously, is an elite defenseman. Leadership, character is impressive. He can play both sides of the ice. He’s a great ⁣skater,” Darche ⁢said.

Darche stated that any team hoping to acquire the top NHL draft pick ‍ would have to make an overwhelming offer. He reiterated his expectation that the Islanders will make the selection themselves, adding a special player to their ranks. The team is using⁣ the‌ scouting combine⁢ to evaluate prospects and consult with their scouting staff to make an informed decision about the​ NHL draft lottery.

What’s next

The Islanders will continue⁣ evaluating prospects, including Matthew Schaefer, leading up to the⁢ NHL Draft on june 27. They aim to select a player​ who can make a significant impact on the team’s future.