Komisi I Minta Panglima TNI Tarik Ribuan Prajurit dari Jabatan Sipil
TNI Personnel in Civilian Roles: A Call for Compliance
Table of Contents
- TNI Personnel in Civilian Roles: A Call for Compliance
- TNI Personnel in Civilian Roles: Navigating the New TNI Law
- What is the central issue surrounding the revised TNI Law?
- Why are active TNI personnel being asked to leave civilian positions?
- What does Article 47 of the TNI Law stipulate?
- Who is calling for compliance with the TNI Law?
- What is the potential impact of these calls for withdrawal?
- How many TNI personnel are estimated to be in civilian roles?
- What kinds of civilian roles do TNI personnel occupy?
- What are the key positions active military officers can hold?
- why is this issue relevant to Indonesian society?
- summarizing the Key Issues
Jakarta – Following the enactment of the revised TNI Law (RUU TNI), calls are growing for the withdrawal of active TNI (Indonesian National Military) personnel from civilian positions. This issue highlights the intersection of military service and civilian governance in Indonesia.
Hasanuddin Urges Compliance wiht TNI Law
TB Hasanuddin, a member of Commission I of the PDIP Faction of the DPR RI (House of Representatives), has urged TNI Commander General Agus Subiyanto to issue an order for the withdrawal of all TNI soldiers from civilian posts. This request follows the formal adoption of the RUU TNI into law.
Hasanuddin expressed his hope that Agus would respect the provisions of Article 47 of the TNI Law, which stipulates that active TNI personnel are permitted to hold positions in 14 ministries and institutions. This legal framework aims to balance military expertise with civilian management.
“Kita harus taat azas. Saya mohon kepada Panglima TNI agar segera mengeluarkan surat perintah, sehingga seluruh prajurit aktif yang berada di luar 14 K/L yang diperbolehkan dapat mengundurkan diri atau pensiun sesuai aturan yang berlaku,”
TB Hasanuddin, DPR RI
Hasanuddin emphasized the importance of adhering to established principles, stating on Friday, March 21, that a formal order should be issued to ensure compliance. He noted that thousands of active TNI personnel currently occupy civilian positions across various sectors, including state-owned enterprises (BUMN), ministries, and other agencies.
Scope of TNI Presence in Civilian Roles
The thousands of soldiers in civilian roles include those serving as staff and aides. While Hasanuddin did not provide precise figures, the critically important number underscores the widespread integration of military personnel into civilian administrative structures.
“Kita ingin memastikan bahwa aturan ini berjalan dengan baik dan semua pihak menjalankan tugasnya sesuai dengan ketentuan yang berlaku,” he stated, emphasizing the need for all parties to fulfill their duties in accordance with existing regulations.
PHBI’s Call for Resignation
Prior to Hasanuddin’s statement, the Perhimpunan Bantuan Hukum dan HAM Indonesia (PHBI), an indonesian legal aid and human rights association, also called for the resignation of thousands of active TNI soldiers currently holding civilian positions, following the ratification of the RUU TNI. This reflects a broader societal concern regarding the role of the military in civilian affairs.
This call stems from the implications of Article 47 paragraph 2 of the revised TNI Law, which states: “Selain menduduki jabatan pada kementerian/lembaga sebagaimana dimaksud pada ayat (1), prajurit dapat menduduki jabatan sipil lain setelah mengundurkan diri atau pensiun dini dari dinas aktif keprajuritan.” (Translation: “Along with holding positions in ministries/institutions as referred to in paragraph (1), soldiers may hold other civilian positions after resigning or retiring early from active military service.”)
“Implikasinya adalah 2.569 prajurit TNI aktif, data per tahun 2023, itu serentak harus mundur. Kalau perlu besok sebagai bentuk konsistensi terhadap tunduknya TNI kepada UU TNI dan juga supremasi sipil,”
Gina Sabrina,Sekretaris Jenderal PBHI
Gina Sabrina,Secretary-General of PBHI,stated on Thursday,March 20,that this implies that 2,569 active TNI soldiers (based on 2023 data) should resign immediately to demonstrate consistency with the TNI Law and civilian supremacy.
Key Takeaways
- Following the enactment of the revised TNI Law, there are increasing calls for active TNI personnel to withdraw from civilian positions.
- TB Hasanuddin urged the TNI Commander to issue a formal order for the withdrawal, emphasizing compliance with Article 47 of the TNI Law.
- The PHBI has also called for the resignation of thousands of active TNI soldiers in civilian roles.
- The core issue revolves around balancing military expertise with civilian governance and upholding the rule of law.
The revised TNI Law in Indonesia has sparked significant discussion regarding the role of military personnel in civilian positions. This article explores the key issues,calls for compliance,and implications of the recent changes.
What is the central issue surrounding the revised TNI Law?
The core issue revolves around the balance between military expertise and civilian governance. The revised TNI Law has led to growing calls for active TNI (Indonesian National Military) personnel to withdraw from civilian positions, emphasizing the need to adhere to legal frameworks and principles of civilian supremacy.
Why are active TNI personnel being asked to leave civilian positions?
Following the enactment of the revised TNI Law, there’s a push for compliance with the law, particularly Article 47. This article outlines the conditions under which active TNI personnel can hold civilian positions. The calls for withdrawal aim to ensure that military involvement in civilian roles complies with the stipulations of the law and respects civilian governance.
What does Article 47 of the TNI Law stipulate?
Article 47 of the TNI law is central to the current debate.It permits active TNI personnel to hold positions in 14 ministries and institutions. However, the law also states that soldiers may hold other civilian positions after resigning or retiring early from active military service.
Who is calling for compliance with the TNI Law?
Several voices are urging compliance:
TB Hasanuddin: A member of the House of Representatives (DPR RI) has urged the TNI Commander general Agus Subiyanto to issue an order for the withdrawal of all TNI soldiers from civilian posts.
Perhimpunan Bantuan Hukum dan HAM Indonesia (PHBI): This indonesian legal aid and human rights association has also called for the resignation of active TNI soldiers holding civilian positions.
What is the potential impact of these calls for withdrawal?
the calls for withdrawal aim to uphold the rule of law and ensure civilian supremacy. Gina Sabrina, Secretary-General of PBHI, has stated that, based on 2023 data, 2,569 active TNI soldiers should resign to demonstrate consistency with the TNI Law.
How many TNI personnel are estimated to be in civilian roles?
While precise figures aren’t provided in the given article, thousands of active TNI personnel currently occupy civilian positions.These roles span across various sectors, including state-owned enterprises (BUMN), ministries, and other agencies.
What kinds of civilian roles do TNI personnel occupy?
The thousands of soldiers in civilian roles include those serving as staff and aides.
What are the key positions active military officers can hold?
According to the sources,active military officers are allowed to take up key civilian positions in 14 ministries and institutions.
why is this issue relevant to Indonesian society?
This issue highlights the intersection of military service and civilian governance in Indonesia. It reflects broader societal concerns regarding the role of the military in civilian affairs and the balance of power within the government.
summarizing the Key Issues
| Issue | Details |
| —————————————- | ———————————————————————————————————- |
| Core Concern | Balancing military expertise with civilian governance and upholding the rule of law. |
| Legal Basis | Article 47 of the TNI Law, which permits active TNI personnel in 14 ministries and institutions. |
| Calls for Action | Urged to withdraw from positions outside the permitted ministries/institutions. |
| Stakeholders | DPR RI members, PHBI, and other concerned parties.|
| Primary Goal | Ensuring compliance with the law, respecting civilian supremacy, and maintaining the integrity of governance. |