Mythical Mountain St Augustine in St. Augustine, Florida

“I make sure to stop here every time I’m In St. Augustine because they always have great collectibles new and classic! If you’re looking for something to complete your collection it’s probably here! The place is packed wall to wall and the prices are average asking for these hard to find pieces.”

— Grizzly Gorilla · ★★★★★ · 2026-2-27

“Closed... again... second time in a few months not open when is showing on website/Google maps... guess my daughter will have to get her toy somewhere else”

— RoB DeYz · ★☆☆☆☆ · 2026-2-11

“A really cool geek shop in downtown St. Augustine. We were browsing and shopping and came across this place and couldn't say no. Glad I pop'd in. Really nice and fun guy working the store. Friendly and helpful. They have a large variety of stuff. Anime and game memorabilia. Lots of D&D stuff and lots of dice for sale. I ended up buying some individual dice from the counter. Highly recommended for all your nerd needs.”

— Joseph Sanchez · ★★★★★ · 2024-3-6

“Gamers this is the place for you!! Tons of different gaming items, figurines, cards, comics (small amount) and misc. items. Friendly and knowledgeable staff let us know the "mega" store is located in Jacksonville, FL...unfortunately we didn't have time to make it there. Hubby purchased a Pokemon battle pack for my collection! (YAY!)”

— Carol Demby · ★★★★★

“Awesome store!! If you’re into collecting … this store is must do. Lots of action figures, new and vintage…collectibles. Customer service was great!”

— B. R. · ★★★★★ · 2023-12-28

“Ignore hard to find reviews... It's in a hallway of little shops, very simple. Store has lots of variety and pretty good prices. Takes a bit to look at everything.”

— Sfx Wolf · ★★★★★

“This place is great, I want to buy everything but am genuinely afraid they would just re-stock and then I would STILL want to buy everything. So, so helpful too”

— Joe LaPorta · ★★★★★ · 2025-5-2

“Outstanding store and service, staff was very helpful with how they keep inventory. Amazing organization skills. Will definitely enjoy my Ghostface statue. Thanks guys, will definitely stop by next time I'm in florida.”

— Dakota Vance · ★★★★★

“A Magical Visit to Mythical Mountain! In charming St. Augustine, there lies a treasure, Mythical Mountain, a book lover’s pleasure! Step through the door and you're whisked away, To lands of adventure where dragons play. The shelves are stacked with wonders untold, From fantasies vast to mysteries bold. Graphic novels with art so divine, Each page invites you, ‘Come and recline.’ With collectibles and comics galore, Every corner brings surprises and more. Figurines and goodies, a fan’s delight, This shop is a haven, a pure delight. The staff are as friendly as elves in a tale, Ready to hel”

— Zane Wylie · ★★★★★

“Love going here when I feel like being downtown! I never really buy anything because I prefer to spend my money on food to be honest- but man I do love to look- and the stuffies and T-shirts are always very tempting :) much love to this place always”

— Amelia Chilling · ★★★★★