Massachusetts Steak Dispute: Man Accused of Fatal Stabbing
- Andrew Horsman, 41, of Massachusetts, faces a murder charge after allegedly stabbing his mother's boyfriend, Paul Pomerleau, 66, during a Saturday night dispute over steaks.
- During Monday's arraignment, prosecutor Nicole Piacentini Lawson said Horsman allegedly stabbed Pomerleau 17 times.
- Horsman fled the scene but was soon apprehended and charged with murder, according to the Middleborough Police Department.
A Massachusetts man, Andrew Horsman, is charged with murder following a fatal stabbing sparked by a dispute over steaks, shocking a community and investigators alike. Horsman, 41, allegedly stabbed Paul Pomerleau, 66, his mother’s boyfriend, a staggering 17 times during the altercation at Pomerleau’s Middleborough residence. Authorities apprehended Horsman after he fled the scene,and pomerleau later succumbed to his injuries. Witnesses and legal representatives offer conflicting accounts, with some suggesting a history of domestic strife and others emphasizing the brutality of the act. News Directory 3 provides comprehensive coverage of this developing story, including statements from the prosecutor and defense. The details of the steak dispute remain unclear, intensifying the interest. Discover what’s next as this case unfolds in the courtroom over the coming weeks.
Massachusetts Man Charged in Steak-Fueled Stabbing
Updated July 1, 2025
Andrew Horsman, 41, of Massachusetts, faces a murder charge after allegedly stabbing his mother’s boyfriend, Paul Pomerleau, 66, during a Saturday night dispute over steaks. The incident occurred at Pomerleau’s Middleborough residence, according to police.
During Monday’s arraignment, prosecutor Nicole Piacentini Lawson said Horsman allegedly stabbed Pomerleau 17 times. After Pomerleau collapsed,Horsman poured lighter fluid on him but was stopped from setting him ablaze by another relative.
Horsman fled the scene but was soon apprehended and charged with murder, according to the Middleborough Police Department. Pomerleau was transported to a local hospital but succumbed to his injuries within an hour.
Lawson stated that horsman resided at the home with his mother and Pomerleau. Witnesses indicated that Pomerleau had previously criticized Horsman for being unemployed and living with his mother.
Joshua Wood, Horsman’s attorney, argued that the violence stemmed from years of alleged domestic abuse. “These people knew each other,” Wood said. “The history wasn’t always peaceful. This wasn’t a random act of violence, but frankly a response to years of suffering.”
The precise details of the steak dispute remain unclear.Peter, Pomerleau’s twin brother, said pomerleau essentially “raised” Horsman. Neighbors expressed shock at Horsman’s alleged actions. “he was like a gentle giant,” neighbor Jeff Burr told WBZ-TV. “He was a great guy.”
Horsman pleaded not guilty at his arraignment and is being held without bail. He is scheduled to return to court July 28.
What’s next
The inquiry is ongoing, and further details regarding the events leading up to the deadly steak dispute are expected to emerge as the case proceeds through the court system.