Mayor of Guérande’s Facebook Rant
- The mayor of Guérande has expressed frustration with legal challenges brought by a heritage protection association, specifically regarding the Saint-Jean district and the old hospital redevelopment.
- According to the mayor, the city has faced multiple legal challenges from an association, involving an elected opposition member, concerning the "Saint-Jean district" project.
- The Saint-Jean district, located near the rue de Sailli and rue de la Juiverie, includes a disused hospital and a chapel, formerly known as the "Doll Museum." The...
guérande Mayor Addresses Delays in saint-Jean District Project
Table of Contents
- guérande Mayor Addresses Delays in saint-Jean District Project
- Guérande’s Saint-Jean District Project: Addressing delays and the Path Forward
- What is the Saint-Jean District Project in Guérande?
- Why is the Saint-Jean District project Facing delays?
- What Are the Main concerns of the Mayor Regarding the Delays?
- What Has the Court Ruled in response to the Challenges?
- What Were the Key Findings of the Court?
- Did the Town Hall Sell the Old Hospital for €850,000?
- When Was the Saint-Jean District Project Approved?
- What Are the Proposed Changes in the Old Buildings?
- Summary of the ProjectTimeline and Legal Challenges.
The mayor of Guérande has expressed frustration with legal challenges brought by a heritage protection association, specifically regarding the Saint-Jean district and the old hospital redevelopment. The mayor believes these appeals are hindering progress on key projects.
The association has not yet issued a public response.
According to the mayor, the city has faced multiple legal challenges from an association, involving an elected opposition member, concerning the “Saint-Jean district” project. These challenges have targeted various aspects of the project, including public-private partnerships, property downgrading procedures, building sales, and building permits. the mayor stated that the court has consistently ruled in favor of the city, rejecting all appeals.
For several years, the city of Guérande paid the price for several legal remedies of an association of which an elected opposition is a member of the file of the “saint-Jean district” in order to slow down the project… the court has finally been right by rejecting all the appeals of our opponents!
The Saint-Jean district, located near the rue de Sailli and rue de la Juiverie, includes a disused hospital and a chapel, formerly known as the “Doll Museum.” The mayor emphasized the urgent need for quality restoration in this historically meaningful, but currently dilapidated, area.
The mayor outlined a proposed project to rehabilitate the old buildings,preserving their architectural integrity and materials,to create new housing and amenities. the plan includes converting the old hospital into 13 additional homes and transforming the chapel into a multi-purpose space for residents and associations.
The mayor stated that after meetings and a municipal council vote in November 2022, the project received approval. Though, further legal challenges from the association have stalled progress.
After multiple meetings with a collective and elected officials against our project… a debate and a democratic vote took place during the municipal council of November 2022 in favor of our proposal… we had the unpleasant surprise to discover several legal remedies of an association of which an elected representative of the opposition is blocking this achievement.
The mayor noted that after three years of legal proceedings, the administrative court has rejected all of the association’s arguments.
After three long years of procedures, all of these requests were rejected by the administrative court by dismantling, one after the other, all the arguments of opponents.
The mayor clarified that the town hall did not sell the old hospital to a developer for €850,000, as alleged by the opposition. The court confirmed that the final price was “clearly higher” than the Domains Service estimate of €190,000 and was justified by reasons of general interest.
Contrary to what the opposing part indicates, the town hall did not sell the old hospital to a promoter by assigning it for € 850,000. The court confirming that the ultimately retained tariff is ”clearly higher” to the estimate of the Domains Service, the amount of which was € 190,000. And also justified by reasons of general interest.
The court also found that municipal elected officials were adequately informed about the deliberations and that the building permit and creation of housing served a general interest.
The mayor expressed concern that further appeals could lead to additional legal costs and divert municipal services from other importent community projects.
The mayor lamented the delays in restoring the old hospital and chapel, stating that it is currently impractical to include the restoration in the budget and schedule. the mayor emphasized the lost time and the impact on improving the city and providing new services.
In the meantime, it is impossible for us to be able to put the restoration of the old hospital and the chapel in the budget (and at the schedule). Three years of lost, perhaps more, to move the lines in our medieval city and provide new services in your daily life!
Guérande’s Saint-Jean District Project: Addressing delays and the Path Forward
This article examines the ongoing project in Guérande’s Saint-Jean district,particularly the redevelopment of the old hospital,and addresses the delays faced by the project. The data is based on a report released by the Mayor of Guérande.
What is the Saint-Jean District Project in Guérande?
The Saint-Jean district project in Guérande involves the rehabilitation of old buildings in a historically significant area, particularly near the rue de sailli and rue de la Juiverie, and includes a disused hospital and a chapel, formerly known as the “Doll Museum.” The project aims to preserve the architectural integrity of these buildings while creating new housing and amenities. the plans include converting the old hospital into 13 new homes and the chapel into a multi-purpose space.
Why is the Saint-Jean District project Facing delays?
The Saint-Jean district project is facing delays primarily due to legal challenges from a heritage protection association. The mayor has stated that these challenges have involved various aspects of the project, including public-private partnerships, property procedures, building sales, and building permits. The association, which includes an elected opposition member, has brought these legal remedies.
What Are the Main concerns of the Mayor Regarding the Delays?
The mayor has expressed several concerns regarding the project delays:
Hindering Progress: The mayor believes the legal challenges are significantly hindering the progress of crucial projects within the city.
Financial Implications: Further appeals could lead to additional legal costs.
Impact on Community Projects: The delays divert municipal services from other vital community projects.
Lost Time: The delays impact the ability to improve the city and provide new services within the planned timeframe, especially the restoration of the old hospital and chapel.
What Has the Court Ruled in response to the Challenges?
The administrative court has consistently ruled in favor of the city, rejecting all appeals made by the heritage protection association. The court dismantled all arguments brought by the opposition.
What Were the Key Findings of the Court?
The court’s key findings include:
Project Approval: The court confirmed that the municipal elected officials were adequately informed about the project deliberations.
General Interest: The court found that the building permit and the creation of housing served a general interest.
* Fair Sale Price: The court confirmed that the final price of the old hospital was justified and higher than the initial estimate.
Did the Town Hall Sell the Old Hospital for €850,000?
No, the mayor clarified that the town hall did not sell the old hospital to a developer for €850,000, as alleged by the opposition. The court confirmed that the final price was ”clearly higher” than the service estimate.
When Was the Saint-Jean District Project Approved?
The project received approval after multiple meetings and a municipal council vote in november 2022.
What Are the Proposed Changes in the Old Buildings?
The plan is to rehabilitate the old buildings while preserving their architectural integrity and materials.The old hospital will be converted into 13 homes, and the chapel will be transformed into a multi-purpose space for residents and associations.
Summary of the ProjectTimeline and Legal Challenges.
| Event | timeline | Outcome |
| ———————————————————– | ————— | ———————————————— |
| Municipal Council Vote | November 2022 | Project Approved |
| Legal Challenges by Heritage Protection Association | Ongoing | Project Stalled |
| Court Proceedings | 3 Years | All appeals rejected by the administrative court |
