Meike S.: Wrongly Accused Doctor Found Guilty
- KASSEL,Germany — Psychological experts testified Wednesday that Meike S., the woman convicted of triple murder for her actions while posing as a doctor, does not have a serious...
- The psychiatrist, Christian Knöchel, repeatedly emphasized that Meike S.could have made diffrent choices.The experts stated that witness testimonies led them to believe she exhibits narcissistic traits rather than...
- The defendant displayed little emotion during the approximately one-hour presentation of the report at the district court.Witnesses, including a close friend and former colleague, noted this behavior during...
Experts: Woman Who Posed as doctor in Germany Was Competent During Murders
Table of Contents
KASSEL,Germany — Psychological experts testified Wednesday that Meike S., the woman convicted of triple murder for her actions while posing as a doctor, does not have a serious mental disorder and is fully culpable for her crimes.
The psychiatrist, Christian Knöchel, repeatedly emphasized that Meike S.could have made diffrent choices.The experts stated that witness testimonies led them to believe she exhibits narcissistic traits rather than a personality disorder.
“Knowing What She Did”
The defendant displayed little emotion during the approximately one-hour presentation of the report at the district court.Witnesses, including a close friend and former colleague, noted this behavior during the initial trial proceedings. Meike S. remained rigid, occasionally shaking her head.
Both experts told the Kassel district court that the woman “knew what she was doing at all times.” They argued that Meike S.’s flexibility ruled out a disorder. Though, she displayed strong narcissistic and histrionic tendencies, seeking attention and behaving dramatically.
Fake Medical License
The 54-year-old worked for years as a doctor in Fritzlar without proper qualifications. She used a falsified license to secure a position as an anesthesiologist at the Hospital zum Heiligen Geist (Hospital to the Holy Spirit).
She worked there from late 2015, practicing as an anesthesiologist from 2016. During this time, she administered anesthesia to approximately 500 patients.Three patients died, and others suffered severe complications.
The experts added that Meike S. continued her deception because she faced little criticism. She likely thought, “Yes, this is working.” This, combined with her knowledge from option medicine training, allowed her to persist.
Conviction and Appeal
In 2022, Meike S. was sentenced to life in prison for three counts of murder and ten counts of attempted murder. She appealed the verdict.
The Federal Court of Justice in Karlsruhe partially overturned the judgment in Febuary 2024. The retrial focuses on the issue of manslaughter and the appropriate sentence. A judgment is expected no earlier than the end of May.
# Experts: Woman Who Posed as Doctor in Germany Was Competent During Murders – Q&A
## Who is Meike S., and What is Her Story?
meike S. is the woman convicted of triple murder in Germany after posing as a doctor. She was initially sentenced to life in prison. The case involves her actions while working as a medical professional, specifically as an anesthesiologist.
## What Were the Crimes Meike S. Was convicted Of?
Meike S. was convicted of three counts of murder and ten counts of attempted murder.
## How Did Meike S. Pose as a Doctor?
According to the provided source, Meike S. used a falsified medical license to secure a position as an anesthesiologist at the Hospital zum Heiligen Geist (Hospital to the Holy Spirit) in Fritzlar. She did not possess the proper qualifications.
## Where Did Meike S. Work, and When?
Meike S. worked at the Hospital zum Heiligen Geist in Fritzlar. She practiced as an anesthesiologist from 2016, after starting in late 2015.
## What Did She Do While Posing as an Anesthesiologist?
During her time as an anesthesiologist, Meike S. administered anesthesia to approximately 500 patients.Sadly,three patients died,and others suffered severe complications.
## What Did Psychological Experts Conclude About Meike S.?
Psychological experts testified that Meike S. does not have a serious mental disorder and is fully culpable for her crimes. They stated she exhibits narcissistic traits but does not suffer from a personality disorder that would absolve her of responsibility. Notably, the experts emphasized that she could have made different choices.
## What Traits Did the Experts Observe in Meike S.?
The experts observed that Meike S. displayed strong narcissistic and histrionic tendencies. She sought attention and behaved dramatically. Witnesses noted her lack of emotion during the trial proceedings, with her remaining rigid and occasionally shaking her head.
## What Does It Mean That She Was “Fully Culpable”?
Being “fully culpable” means Meike S. was considered responsible for her actions. The experts’ testimony indicated that she understood what she was doing and could have chosen different actions.
## What Role Did her Deception Play in the Murders?
The experts suggested that Meike S. continued her deception as she faced little criticism, leading her to believe her actions were acceptable. This, combined with her knowledge from option medicine training, allowed her to persist in her fraudulent behavior.
## What Happened after Meike S. Was Initially Convicted?
in 2022, Meike S. was sentenced to life in prison. She appealed the verdict.
## What is the Current Status of Her Case?
The Federal Court of Justice in Karlsruhe partially overturned the judgment in February 2024. This means there will be a retrial. The retrial focuses on the issue of manslaughter and the appropriate sentence. A judgment is expected no earlier than the end of May.
## Key Timeline of Events:
Here’s a summary:
| Year | Event |
|---|---|
| Late 2015 | meike S. began working at the hospital zum Heiligen Geist in Fritzlar. |
| 2016 | Meike S. began practicing as an anesthesiologist. |
| 2022 | Meike S. was sentenced to life in prison. |
| Febuary 2024 | The Federal Court of Justice partially overturned the judgment. |
| expected: end of May | Possible judgment in the retrial. |