Michael Kay & Don Mattingly Mediate Blue Jays Feud
Michael Kay Explains Blue Jays comments to John Schneider, But Fans Aren’t Buying It
Table of Contents
Yankees broadcaster Michael kay is still feeling the heat from Blue Jays fans after his controversial comments earlier this season, where he declared the Toronto team “not a first-place team.” Despite the Blue Jays currently holding first place over the Yankees, Kay has been attempting to clarify his remarks, insisting he was trying to compliment the team’s performance relative to their underlying metrics.
Kay’s “Compliment” Backfires
The situation escalated when the Blue Jays, defying Kay’s assessment, surged ahead of the Yankees in the standings. This success has led to a barrage of social media mockery directed at Kay every time the Blue Jays secure a victory. Kay maintains that his intention was to praise the Blue Jays for outperforming their run differential, not to insult them.
“I think I might have said they’re not playing that great because I was looking at the numbers and I probably didn’t articulate it the way I should have,” Kay told the Toronto Star. “They were playing better than you would think they were playing when you looked at their numbers.”
Reaching Out to the Dugout
Unwilling to let the misunderstanding fester, Kay decided to reach out to Blue Jays manager John Schneider.To facilitate this communication, Kay contacted his former broadcast partner and current Blue Jays bench coach, Don Mattingly.
“I just reached out to Donnie, I said, ’Can you tell Schneider what I meant?’ and than donnie actually told Schneider and Schneider contacted me,” Kay revealed to the Toronto Star. “We had a text exchange and he said, ‘I totally understand, you don’t have to clarify anything, I know exactly what you mean.'”
Kay expressed frustration with the public perception of his actions, stating, “People don’t wont to believe it, they think I’m backtracking when I’m not.”
The Unforgettable Remark
The core of the controversy lies in Kay’s assertion that the Blue Jays were “not a first-place team…they’re not playing great baseball.” This statement, made just as Toronto began to overtake the Yankees, proved to be a rallying cry for Blue Jays supporters. For any fanbase, hearing a prominent announcer from a rival team dismiss their team’s standing is unlikely to be taken with grace.
A Persistent Taunt
While Kay’s efforts to explain his perspective to schneider, via Mattingly, demonstrate a desire to clear the air, it truly seems unlikely to sway the Blue Jays faithful. The narrative has taken on a life of its own,becoming a source of amusement and a point of pride for Toronto fans. As long as the Blue Jays remain ahead of the Yankees, Kay’s earlier pronouncement will likely continue to be a favorite taunt, regardless of his explanations. The team’s on-field success has, in the eyes of many fans, definitively proven Kay wrong.