Fight Night: Million Dollar Heist

WARNING: This post contains spoilers.

On October 26, 1970, Muhammad Ali made a historic comeback to the boxing ring after a three-and-a-half-year absence due to his religious objections to enlisting in the U.S. military. Ali’s resistance led to his conviction for draft evasion and his stripping of all his titles. His anti-war stance was met with both praise and ridicule, and a fight between Ali and heavyweight boxer Jerry Quaree in Atlanta became an international sporting spectacle.

The sold-out game at the Atlanta Municipal Auditorium drew a huge crowd. The late boxing writer Bert Sugar explained: “The greatest gathering of black power and money ever assembled,” it brought together a diverse array of notables, from celebrities to civil rights leaders, politicians to gangsters. So when Ali won in a landslide victory in the third round, Atlanta erupted in celebration. The night became a major cultural milestone for the city, solidifying its status as the “black mecca” of the American South.

“It was more than just a fight, it was a huge moment for Atlanta.” Civil rights activist Julian Bond recalls the impact of that night. “That night, Atlanta became the capital of African-American politics.”

Peacock’s new limited series Fight Night: Million Dollar Heist centers around the events surrounding a certain after-party where hundreds of guests were robbed, stripped naked, and forced to hand over cash and jewelry. The film follows local conman Gordon “Chickenman” Williams as he organizes parties on the orders of notorious New York underworld crime lord Frank Morten, known as the “Black Father”, and his New Jersey partner Richard “Cadillac” Wheeler, who eventually becomes one of the prime suspects in the case.

How the Theft Happened

<figure class="block h-auto w-full inline-image self-center max-w-full" aria-label="media" data-block="gutenberg-custom-blocks/inline-image" data-media-size="special_small_2x" data-original-width="1000" data-original-height="727" data-original-src="https://api.time.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/09/Fight-Night-Taraji-P-Henson.jpg?quality=85" data-caption="Taraji P. Henson as Vivian Thomas in Fight Night: The Million Dollar Heist” data-credit=”Parrish Lewis—Peacock”>

Hours after Ali’s victory, about 200 partygoers stormed into a private home in Atlanta for what they thought would be a lavish Vegas-style party. Instead, they were taken hostage by masked men wielding shotguns, who took them to the basement of the home and stole their money and belongings.

Atlanta’s Alternative News reported in 2004 that the basement eventually became so cramped that the gunmen ordered the victims to lie on top of each other. “Cash and jewelry were swept into pillowcases,” the report said. “This continued for hours as more and more people arrived. By 3 a.m., the half-naked victims were piled on top of each other like firewood.”

When JD Hudson, one of the first black detectives on the desegregated Atlanta police force, takes charge of the case, he finds that many partygoers are reluctant to talk to the police. Only five victims have filed formal complaints, but the robbers are believed to have stolen at least $1 million worth of stolen goods.

Chicken Man, who hosted the party and had a long criminal record, was soon suspected of planning the robbery to repay a debt, which put him at risk of crime bosses seeking revenge for his actions. On November 18, 1970, three men, McKinley Rogers Jr., James Henry Hall, and Houston J. Hammond, were finally charged with armed robbery. While Hammond was in police custody, Rogers and Hall were shot and killed in the Bronx in May 1971 in what was believed to be a revenge killing.

What Happened to Chicken Man?

<figure class="block h-auto w-full inline-image self-center max-w-full" aria-label="media" data-block="gutenberg-custom-blocks/inline-image" data-media-size="special_small_2x" data-original-width="1000" data-original-height="686" data-original-src="https://api.time.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/09/Fight-Night-Terrence-Howard-Samuel-L-Jackson.jpg?quality=85" data-caption="(L-R): Terrence Howard as Cadillac Richie, Samuel L. Jackson as Frank Moten, and Michael James Shaw as Lamar in Fight Night: The Million Dollar Heist.” data-credit=”Parrish Lewis—Peacock”>

Many people believe that Chicken Man was killed on a contract made a few days after the robbery, but 30 years later, in a 2002 interview with Fight Night podcast writer and host Jeff Keating, Hudson said Williams actually survived the ordeal and is still living and working as a pastor in Atlanta. “The Chicken Man is alive today,” he said. “He’s Pastor Gordon Williams of Salem Baptist Church.”

Two years later, when Hudson and Williams met at Williams’ church, arranged by Keating, Hudson explained why he came to believe the Chicken Man was innocent.

“I knew he wasn’t stupid enough to do something like that,” Hudson told Creative Loafing. “He’s a guy who runs a multi-million dollar business from a payphone around the corner. He’s smart. He can run IBM or Coca-Cola. There’s no way he’d risk all that to bribe someone. This was a bunch of young thugs trying to ruin a party. They got there, saw the size of the party, and improvised.”