NAM Dinh Hospital Denies Emergency Payment Requirement for Pediatric Patients
- NAM DINH, Vietnam – Authorities are investigating a hospital in Nam Dinh province following allegations that a 4-year-old child was initially denied emergency treatment due to payment concerns....
- TT, who accompanied MTA to the hospital, claimed in the video that medical staff hesitated to provide immediate care due to insufficient funds.
- nam Dinh Provincial General Hospital released a report on May 4 addressing the allegations.
Nam Dinh Hospital Investigated After Child’s Emergency Care Delay
Table of Contents
NAM DINH, Vietnam – Authorities are investigating a hospital in Nam Dinh province following allegations that a 4-year-old child was initially denied emergency treatment due to payment concerns. teh incident, which occurred May 3, sparked public outrage after a video circulated on social media.
Tractor Accident and Initial Response
According to reports, the child, identified as MTA, was struck by a tractor that allegedly fled the scene. Bystanders transported the injured child to Nam Dinh Provincial General Hospital. Family members were not immediately present.
Allegations of Delayed Treatment
A person identified as Mr. TT, who accompanied MTA to the hospital, claimed in the video that medical staff hesitated to provide immediate care due to insufficient funds. “I ran a red light to get my child to the emergency room,” Mr. TT reportedly saeid, “but I only had 500,000 VND. The doctors said I had to have enough money for emergency treatment.” He expressed frustration that the child, injured in a tractor accident, waited approximately 10 minutes before receiving care.
Hospital’s Version of Events
nam Dinh Provincial General Hospital released a report on May 4 addressing the allegations. The hospital stated that MTA arrived at 4:30 p.m. on May 3, conscious and crying, with a scratch on the right elbow. According to the report, the child was examined by orthopedic and general surgeons, and diagnostic tests were ordered at 4:10 p.m., including scans, ultrasounds, and X-rays, before registration and payment.
The hospital further stated that scan results were available by 4:20 p.m., and complete radiography and ultrasound results by 4:40 p.m. Following these tests, doctors prescribed medication, IV fluids, and emergency treatment. MTA was then transferred to the National Children’s Hospital at 5:45 p.m. the same day.
Possible Miscommunication Claimed
The hospital acknowledged that an advance payment of 500,000 VND was requested during the examination and testing phase. Though, the hospital claims staff processed administrative procedures to avoid requiring additional deposits. The hospital’s report suggests a possible miscommunication, stating that the medical staff did not directly tell Mr. TT that full payment was required before emergency care. They suggest Mr. TT may have misinterpreted discussions about administrative procedures.
The hospital also noted that MTA’s parents, who arrived later, did not raise any concerns during the emergency treatment.
Ministry of Health Investigates
The Ministry of Health is also involved. Ha Anh Duke, director of the ministry’s medical examinations and treatment management department, stated that they are requesting reports from both the Nam Dinh provincial health department and the Nam Dinh Provincial General Hospital to clarify the situation. According to Duke, the ministry is committed to enforcing regulations regarding emergency care for accident victims.
# Nam Dinh Hospital Examination: What You Need to Know
## What’s Happening at Nam Dinh Provincial General Hospital?
Authorities in Nam Dinh province, Vietnam, are investigating Nam dinh Provincial General Hospital. The investigation stems from allegations that a 4-year-old child, identified as MTA, was initially denied emergency treatment due to payment concerns. this incident, which occurred on May 3rd, sparked public outrage after a video circulated on social media.
## What Happened to the Child?
On May 3rd,MTA was reportedly struck by a tractor that fled the scene.Bystanders brought the injured child to nam Dinh Provincial General Hospital. Family members were not immediately present.
## Why is the Hospital Under Investigation?
The investigation centers on claims of delayed treatment. A person identified as Mr. TT,who accompanied MTA to the hospital,alleged that medical staff hesitated to provide immediate care due to insufficient funds. Mr. TT claimed he onyl had 500,000 VND at the time. He stated the doctors said he needed to have enough money for emergency treatment. The child, injured in a tractor accident, reportedly waited approximately 10 minutes before receiving care.
## What is the Hospital’s Response?
Nam Dinh Provincial General Hospital issued a report on May 4th addressing the allegations.The hospital’s version of events differs somewhat from the claims made by Mr. TT.
## What are the Key Differences in the Accounts?
Here’s a summary based on the provided information:
| Aspect | Mr. TT’s Account | Hospital’s Account |
|---|---|---|
| Treatment Delay | Claimed a delay due to lack of funds. | Acknowledged 10-minute wait but attributed it to examination and testing before treatment. |
| Initial Condition | Implied immediate care wasn’t given. | Stated MTA was conscious and crying, with a scratch on the elbow. |
| Payment Concerns | Implied payment was a barrier to immediate care. | Admitted to requesting a 500,000 VND advance payment but claimed administrative procedures were followed, suggesting possible miscommunication. |
## What Did the Hospital Actually Do?
According to the hospital’s report:
* MTA arrived at 4:30 p.m. on May 3rd.
* The child was examined by orthopedic and general surgeons.
* Diagnostic tests (scans, ultrasounds, and X-rays) were ordered at 4:10 p.m., before registration and payment.
* Scan results were available by 4:20 p.m.
* Complete radiography and ultrasound results by 4:40 p.m.
* Doctors prescribed medication, IV fluids, and emergency treatment after the tests.
* MTA was transferred to the National Children’s Hospital at 5:45 p.m.
## What Explains the Alleged Delay?
The hospital suggests a possible miscommunication. They claim staff processed administrative procedures to avoid requiring additional deposits, and that medical staff didn’t directly tell Mr. TT full payment was required before care. They suggest Mr.TT misinterpreted discussions about administrative procedures.
## Is Anyone Else involved in the Investigation?
Yes, the Ministry of Health is investigating the situation. Ha anh Duke, director of the ministry’s medical examinations and treatment management department, stated that they are requesting reports from both the Nam Dinh provincial health department and Nam Dinh Provincial General Hospital to clarify the situation. The ministry is committed to enforcing regulations regarding emergency care for accident victims.
## What Happens Next?
The investigation is ongoing.