Nyayamurti DK Sharma – ThePrint Hindi
“`html
Delhi High Court Judge Transferred Amid Bar Association Opposition
Table of Contents
- Delhi High Court Judge Transferred Amid Bar Association Opposition
- Delhi High Court Judge Transferred Amid Bar Association Opposition
- Why was justice Dinesh Kumar Sharma transferred from the Delhi High Court?
- what was the reaction to Justice Sharma’s transfer?
- What is the Bar Council of India’s stance on judicial transfers?
- What did Justice Sharma say about the transfer and the opposition from the Kolkata Bar Association?
- what is the role of the judiciary in india?
- What are some notable rulings made by Justice Sharma?
- Who else was transferred recently?
- what is the purpose of judicial transfers?
- How dose the transfer process work?
- what did Chief Justice D.K. Upadhyay say about Justice Sharma?
- Summary of Key Points
NEW DELHI (April 4, 2025) — Justice Dinesh Kumar Sharma of the Delhi High Court addressed the concerns of Kolkata lawyers regarding his transfer to the Calcutta High Court, stating he holds no ill will despite their disagreement.
Speaking at his farewell ceremony, Sharma expressed gratitude for the legal community’s dedication to justice. He pledged to serve the institution to the best of his ability.
“I want to assure the Kolkata Bar Association that I will serve the institution according to my ability and resolution,” Sharma said. “I respect the disagreement expressed by the Kolkata Bar Association. He has the right to express his disagreement and I fully respect him, and there is no resentment in my heart. I respect them all.”
Sharma also voiced his commitment to upholding the Constitution and serving all citizens.
Lawyers Protest Transfer
Earlier in the week, lawyers in Kolkata voiced their opposition to the transfer by submitting a memorandum to the Calcutta High court’s Chief Justice. They also indicated they would abstain from justice Sharma’s swearing-in ceremony and court proceedings.
Bar Council of India Weighs In
Ved Prakash Sharma, vice president of the Bar Council of india (BCI), spoke at the farewell ceremony in Delhi, characterizing the judicial transfer system as an “integral” component designed to safeguard the judiciary’s independence and integrity.
Sharma stated that judicial transfers should be a seamless process. He added that while differing opinions are inevitable, maintaining collective duty is crucial for the smooth functioning of the courts and preserving public trust.
Sameer Vasistha, a permanent lawyer for the delhi government, urged the Calcutta Bar Association to uphold its duty to administer justice. He cautioned against hasty conclusions based on “united allegations.”
Praise for Justice Sharma
Chief Justice D.K. Upadhyay lauded Justice Sharma’s humility and noted that his three decades of judicial experience where invaluable.
Justice Sharma emphasized that a judge’s role extends beyond simply applying the law; it requires clarity and compassion.
Recent Transfers
Justice Sharma’s transfer from Delhi to the calcutta High Court took affect April 1. Justices Yashwant Verma and Chandra Dhari Singh have also been transferred recently. Sharma is the third judge to be transferred.
The Supreme Court Collegium recommended Justice Sharma’s transfer in late March.
Notable Rulings
In September 2024, Sharma granted interim bail to co-owners jailed in connection with the deaths by drowning of three civil service exam candidates at a coaching center in Old rajendra Nagar.
In March 2024, he upheld the CBI’s appeal against the acquittal of former Telecom Minister A Raja and 16 others in the 2G spectrum allocation case.
In March 2023, acting as a tribunal under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, Sharma affirmed the central government’s decision to declare the Popular Front of India an illegal
Delhi High Court Judge Transferred Amid Bar Association Opposition
Why was justice Dinesh Kumar Sharma transferred from the Delhi High Court?
Justice Dinesh Kumar Sharma was transferred from the Delhi High Court to the Calcutta High Court. The Supreme Court Collegium recommended the transfer in late March.
what was the reaction to Justice Sharma’s transfer?
Lawyers in Kolkata voiced their opposition to the transfer, submitting a memorandum to the Calcutta High Court’s Chief Justice. They also indicated they would abstain from Justice Sharma’s swearing-in ceremony and court proceedings.
What is the Bar Council of India’s stance on judicial transfers?
Ved Prakash Sharma, vice president of the Bar Council of India (BCI), characterized the judicial transfer system as an “integral” component designed to safeguard the judiciary’s independence and integrity. He stated that judicial transfers should be a seamless process.
What did Justice Sharma say about the transfer and the opposition from the Kolkata Bar Association?
At his farewell ceremony, Justice sharma expressed gratitude to the legal community and pledged to serve the institution to the best of his ability. He stated, “I respect the disagreement expressed by the Kolkata Bar Association… and there is no resentment in my heart. I respect them all.” He also voiced his commitment to upholding the Constitution and serving all citizens.
what is the role of the judiciary in india?
The core function of the judiciary, and therefore a judge, is to apply the law and uphold the Constitution. Justice Sharma emphasized that a judge’s role extends beyond simply applying the law; it requires clarity and compassion. Judges are expected to ensure impartiality,fairness,and the protection of the rights of all citizens.
What are some notable rulings made by Justice Sharma?
Justice Sharma has presided over several significant cases. Here are a few key examples:
- In September 2024, he granted interim bail to co-owners involved in the deaths of civil service exam candidates.
- In March 2024, he upheld the CBI’s appeal in the 2G spectrum allocation case.
- In March 2023, he affirmed the government’s decision to declare the Popular Front of India an illegal association.
These rulings demonstrate Justice Sharma’s involvement in cases spanning various areas of law.
Who else was transferred recently?
Besides Justice Sharma, Justices Yashwant Verma and Chandra Dhari Singh have also been transferred.
what is the purpose of judicial transfers?
According to the Bar Council of India, judicial transfers are an “integral” component designed to safeguard the judiciary’s independence and integrity. The goal is to ensure judges can perform their duties impartially and that the judicial system is not susceptible to undue influence.
How dose the transfer process work?
The supreme Court Collegium, which consists of the Chief Justice of India and the senior-most judges of the Supreme Court, recommends the transfer of judges. This recommendation is then usually followed.
what did Chief Justice D.K. Upadhyay say about Justice Sharma?
Chief Justice D.K. Upadhyay lauded Justice Sharma’s humility and noted that his three decades of judicial experience were invaluable.
Summary of Key Points
Here’s a table summarizing the essential aspects of the story:
| Key Event | details |
|---|---|
| Transfer announced | Justice Dinesh Kumar Sharma transferred from Delhi to Calcutta High Court. |
| Opposition to Transfer | Kolkata lawyers opposed the transfer, submitting a memorandum. |
| Bar Council of India’s Stance | Views transfer system as crucial for judicial independence. |
| Justice Sharma’s Response | Expressed respect for dissenting views and commitment to duty. |
| Recent Transfers | Justices Yashwant Verma and Chandra Dhari Singh were also transferred. |
| Notable Rulings | included rulings on bail, 2G spectrum, and the Popular Front of India. |