Paul Krugman calls on US to reclaim Starlink control

Nobel laureate Paul Krugman called on the United States to immediately reclaim control of the Starlink satellite communication network from billionaire Elon Musk, warning that private control of modern military infrastructure poses severe risks to national sovereignty and international security.

Krugman Cites Ukraine Starlink Restrictions

The controversy centers on allegations that SpaceX founder Elon Musk cut off or restricted frontline internet access for Ukrainian forces, a move that critics argue directly interferes in an active international conflict. Krugman wrote in his column that deliberately degrading satellite communications amounts to a private party directly intervening in geopolitics, which weakens Ukrainian defensive capabilities and hands an advantage to Russian forces.

Ukraine’s Ministry of Defense signed a letter of intent with Finnish space tech startup ICEYE and telecom giant Nokia to explore developing an independently controlled sovereign satellite communications system. The first satellites are expected to be launched in 2028. Reuters reported that Ukrainian officials stated Starlink speed limits on high-speed mobile platforms exceeding 160 kilometers per hour remain unresolved, despite claims from U.S. officials that the service issues had been addressed.

F-16 Fighter Jet Comparison Raises Stakes for Taiwan

Rejecting arguments that private companies hold absolute rights over their own property, Krugman used a hypothetical scenario involving Taiwan’s air force to illustrate the limits of corporate autonomy in defense matters. He asked whether any democratic society would view it as legitimate commerce if Lockheed Martin abruptly halted the delivery of F-16 fighter jet spare parts, software updates, and munitions to Taiwan to secure a business deal elsewhere. In such a crisis, governments would inevitably intervene to protect their defense interests, proving that capitalist ownership structures cannot override national security.

Krugman referenced World War II history to establish legal precedent for government seizure of private assets during wartime. When Montgomery Ward department store chairman Sewell Avery refused to comply with government labor directives in 1944, President Franklin D. Roosevelt dispatched troops to seize the company’s facilities and physically remove the executive. Krugman argued that just as heavy artillery and precision missiles dictate battlefield outcomes, immediate satellite networks and data flow are now foundational military assets that must remain under the command of democratically accountable governments rather than individual tech executives.

More on Starlink: Starlink Restores High Speeds in Ukraine After U.S. Restrictions · Starlink Travel Rules Block South African Roaming Users · SpaceX Launches 27 Starlink Satellites on Falcon 9 Rocket