Russia has escalated its control over the digital landscape, officially blocking WhatsApp on . The move, confirmed by the Kremlin, follows weeks of restrictions and comes as Moscow pushes citizens towards a domestically developed messaging app, Max. This action mirrors earlier restrictions placed on Telegram, highlighting a broader strategy to exert greater oversight over online communication within the country.
The stated reason for the block, according to Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov, is Meta’s – WhatsApp’s parent company – “unwillingness to comply with the norms and the letter of Russian law.” Specifically, Russia has demanded that messaging services store Russian users’ data within the country and provide access to that data upon request for investigations related to fraud and activities deemed “terrorist.” Rights advocates fear these demands will extend Russia’s surveillance capabilities and potentially target dissenters, critics of the Kremlin, or those opposing the war in Ukraine.
WhatsApp’s Role in Russia
WhatsApp, owned by US tech giant Meta, boasted over 100 million users in Russia as of , making it a dominant messaging platform, particularly among Russians aged 25 and older. While Telegram held greater popularity with younger demographics, WhatsApp’s widespread adoption made it a significant target for Russian regulators. Prior to the full block, Russia had already begun throttling WhatsApp’s service last , citing concerns about its use in facilitating criminal activity. A complete ban was threatened in if the company did not comply with Russian legislation.
WhatsApp responded to the block by stating that the Russian government had “attempted to fully block” the service “in an effort to drive people to a state-owned surveillance app.” The company emphasized that isolating over 100 million users from secure communication represents a step backwards and could compromise the safety of individuals within Russia. Despite the block, reports suggest that users employing Virtual Private Networks (VPNs) are still able to circumvent the restrictions, at least for now.
Telegram: A Complex Relationship
The restrictions on WhatsApp are occurring concurrently with increased pressure on Telegram, a platform founded by Russian-born entrepreneur Pavel Durov. Russia’s internet watchdog began throttling access to Telegram on , citing similar concerns about non-compliance with Russian legislation. However, the situation with Telegram is more nuanced.
Despite the restrictions, Telegram remains a highly popular platform in Russia, with over one billion monthly active users globally. Notably, Russian officials, including those within the Kremlin, continue to utilize Telegram to disseminate information, and it serves as a primary outlet for pro-government military bloggers commenting on the war in Ukraine. Some analysts suggest that a complete ban on Telegram could disrupt communications on the front lines and within Russian-occupied territories.
Durov himself has been critical of the Kremlin’s actions, characterizing the restrictions as an attempt to force citizens onto a state-controlled app designed for surveillance and political censorship. Durov’s history with Russian authorities is fraught with tension; he was previously forced out of VK, a Russian social media platform he founded, under pressure from the government. Russia previously attempted a two-year ban on Telegram, ultimately lifting it in after failing to effectively restrict access or curb its growth.
The Rise of Max
At the heart of Russia’s strategy lies Max, a “super app” developed by Russian social media giant VK. Launched last year, Max aims to emulate the functionality of platforms like China’s WeChat and Alipay, offering a wide range of services, from accessing government services to ordering food. The Russian government has actively promoted Max, even mandating that it be pre-installed on all new phones and tablets starting in . By , VK claimed Max had reached 75 million users.
However, Max has faced skepticism from some Russians. Reports indicate that some individuals have been compelled to download the app by their employers. A key concern surrounding Max is its lack of end-to-end encryption, unlike WhatsApp. This means that messages are not scrambled during transmission and could potentially be intercepted and retained by the state. Digital rights NGO Roskomsvoboda co-founder Sarkis Darbinyan suggests that shifting users to Max could allow authorities to limit access to information deemed undesirable, creating a “vacuum” where users are shielded from dissenting viewpoints.
Russia’s actions represent a significant escalation in its efforts to control the flow of information and monitor its citizens online. The blocking of WhatsApp, coupled with the pressure on Telegram and the promotion of Max, underscores a clear intent to establish a “sovereign internet” – a digital space under the firm control of the Russian government.
