background: The Split and dispute

A Spanish ‍court ordered the provisional release of ⁢two nuns detained on ‌Thursday, November 28, 2024, ⁢as part ⁢of an ​investigation into ‌the alleged misappropriation ⁣of cultural⁤ heritage assets. The nuns belong to a group of nine from the ⁣Order of Saint clare who separated from the Vatican in May 2024 ​following a dispute over ⁤property rights and theological differences, a situation that has garnered significant attention in Spain.

The ‌Archbishopric of⁢ Burgos had requested the nuns vacate their 15th-century convent in Belorado,asserting they had no‍ legal basis to remain after their excommunication. However, the nuns defied an earlier court order for eviction, maintaining their‌ claim to ownership of the convent and appealing the decision.

The Investigation and Arrests

The‍ Civil Guard, Spain’s national​ police force, conducted a search of the ⁢convent to determine if the former nuns had illicitly sold pieces of sacred art, according to reporting by El⁣ País. ⁣ an antiquarian suspected of⁣ receiving the items was also⁢ taken‌ into ⁤custody ⁢and has as been released.

In a statement posted on social media on Thursday, the nuns asserted their innocence, stating, “We have committed no crime and we ‌have nothing⁤ to hide.”

Doctrinal Differences and Excommunication

The nuns have pledged allegiance to an ultra-conservative​ priest who has been excommunicated by the Catholic Church. this priest rejects the legitimacy of all popes since‍ the death of Pope‌ Pius XII ⁢in 1958. The Church officially​ considers this ⁤movement a sect.

The Order of saint Clare,⁤ founded by Saint Clare of Assisi in 1212, traditionally emphasizes poverty and a⁢ contemplative life. The Vatican’s official website provides further facts on the order’s history and charism.

Legal Status and Ongoing ​Appeal

The court in Briviesca confirmed it​ had ordered the release of the two ⁢nuns while the​ investigation continues. The​ nuns’ appeal against their ‌eviction from the belorado convent remains pending. The legal battle centers on the ownership ‍of the property and the validity of the excommunication⁣ in relation to property rights.