Swiss Mayor Faces Criticism After Outburst Over Parking Payment Methods
Marcus Beer, the mayor of Ilanz/Glion in the Swiss canton of Graubünden, faced a wave of criticism earlier this month after a heated exchange with citizens demanding the option to pay for parking with cash. A video of the incident, which occurred in early February, shows the mayor reportedly saying, “You are acting to the detriment of the youth. The youth pays the s*** that a few old people want. You are irresponsible!”
Beer later issued an apology, stating his reaction was “emotional and unprofessional.” He also criticized the surreptitious filming and subsequent publication of the video. He announced he would put a motion of no confidence in himself to the municipal parliament at its next session, stating, “Parliament will be able to decide whether I am still viable for the office of mayor.” However, as reported by “Blick”, Graubünden does not have a process for removing a mayor from office.
Tension Reached a Peak at Wednesday’s Session
The municipal parliament convened on Wednesday evening, with the hall filled with spectators, including plainclothes police officers. The key item on the agenda was Beer’s motion of no confidence.
Do you pay at parking meters with cash or the app?
Beer apologized again, stating, according to “Blick”, “For me, it is not a problem to submit my resignation. I am not clinging to this office.” He added, “I wanted to say that we older people could be a little more modest.” He also cautioned against generalizing about seniors, stating, “There are also many reasonable people among the older generation.”
No Debate Allowed on the Motion
In a surprising turn, Parliament President Flavio Elvedi refused to allow any discussion or vote on the motion of no confidence. He stated that it was “simply not lawful” to proceed. Elvedi concluded by saying, “My colleagues. It is not up to us to deal with or comment on this motion of no confidence.”
The incident highlights a local dispute over payment options for public parking, but also raises questions about the conduct expected of elected officials and the limits of their accountability within the Swiss political system. According to a Reddit discussion on r/askswitzerland, while individual commissioners or politicians cannot be removed before the end of their term, the entire commission or assembly can be voted out.
