The Last Dinner Party Cover LCD Soundsystem in NYC – Setlist & Video

The Last Dinner Party marked their two-show run at New York City’s Hammerstein Ballroom with a cover of LCD Soundsystem’s 2007 hit, ‘New York, I Love You But You’re Bringing Me Down’ on Saturday, April 25.

The performance of the LCD Soundsystem classic served as the first of a three-song encore for the English rock outfit, according to reporting from NME.

The band opened their set with ‘Agnus Dei’ and ‘Count The Ways’, both tracks from their recently released album, ‘From The Pyre’. The setlist blended material from ‘From The Pyre’ with songs from their 2024 debut album, ‘Prelude To Ecstasy’.

Adding to the surprise for fans, The Last Dinner Party debuted two unreleased songs during the show: ‘Big Dog’ and ‘Knocking At The Sky’. The main set concluded with their 2023 debut single, ‘Nothing Matters’.

Setlist Details

• ‘Agnus Dei’
• ‘Count the Ways’
• ‘The Feminine Urge’
• ‘Caesar on a TV Screen’
• ‘On Your Side’
• ‘Second Best’
• ‘I Hold Your Anger’
• ‘Woman Is a Tree’
• ‘Gjuha’
• ‘Rifle’
• ‘Big Dog (unreleased)’
• ‘Mirror’
• ‘The Scythe’
• ‘Sail Away’
• ‘Sinner’
• ‘My Lady of Mercy’
• ‘Inferno’
• ‘Knocking at the Sky (unreleased)’
• ‘Nothing Matters’

Encore Performance

• ‘New York, I Love You But You’re Bringing Me Down (LCD Soundsystem Cover)’
• ‘This Is the Killer Speaking’
• ‘Agnus Dei (Reprise)’

Following the LCD Soundsystem cover, the encore continued with ‘This Is the Killer Speaking’, a single from ‘From The Pyre’, and a reprise of ‘Agnus Dei’.

The Last Dinner Party’s latest album, ‘From The Pyre’, was described by Rhian Daly of NME as “a darker, more accomplished return.” Daly continued in her four-star review that the album is “still as deliciously dramatic as ‘Prelude To Ecstasy’, fleshing out their world more and more with daring, dashing songs of true depth.”

The band recently participated in the 2026 Secret 7″ vinyl record auction, joining artists such as Glass Animals and John Lennon to support the charity War Child.

The performance at the Hammerstein Ballroom highlights The Last Dinner Party’s growing presence in the music scene, following the success of their debut album and the release of ‘From The Pyre’. The unexpected cover of LCD Soundsystem’s iconic track provided a memorable moment for fans in attendance.