US Response to Putin: A Strategic Warning – The Cipher Brief
- The situation in Ukraine remains critically unresolved, with no agreement reached and maximum pressure yet to be applied.
- First, Russian President Vladimir Putin demonstrates no intention of concluding the war he initiated on terms other than his own, terms unchanged since the conflict began.
- Regardless of any conflicting messages delivered by Trump's envoy, Steve Witkoff, President Trump must now recognize Putin's unwavering intentions.
The situation in Ukraine remains critically unresolved, with no agreement reached and maximum pressure yet to be applied. Despite recent events,a clear path forward remains elusive,but several key realities have emerged.
First, Russian President Vladimir Putin demonstrates no intention of concluding the war he initiated on terms other than his own, terms unchanged since the conflict began. Putin seeks to occupy all of Ukraine, and if military force proves insufficient, he aims to establish a 21st-century equivalent of Vichy France in the remaining territories.
Regardless of any conflicting messages delivered by Trump’s envoy, Steve Witkoff, President Trump must now recognize Putin’s unwavering intentions. Russia’s continued bombing of Ukrainian civilian targets - both during and outside of negotiation periods, including before and after the Anchorage, Alaska summit - underscores Putin’s brutality and his belief in a military victory.
President Trump should also acknowledge that granting Putin a meeting on U.S.soil without prior concessions was a tactical, and potentially strategic, error. This move ended Putin’s diplomatic isolation, provided valuable propaganda for domestic consumption, and appeared to disregard his status as an indicted war criminal.
Putin framed the summit as a meeting of equals,a narrative amplified by Russian media. This perception is misleading, as Russia’s power lies primarily in its nuclear arsenal, while the U.S. holds economic,military,and cultural dominance. Consequently, anchorage represented a significant win for Putin and an embarrassment for the U.S., though this can still be rectified.
The Cipher Brief provides expert-level context to national and global security stories. Understanding the evolving world requires access to exclusive content. Become a subscriber to upgrade your access.
The subsequent White House meeting showcased impressive allied solidarity, including Ukraine and key European leaders. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky demonstrated a learned approach, consistently praising President Trump and acknowledging U.S.support since the full-scale invasion.
NATO allies have also learned to navigate Putin’s manipulative tactics, successfully engaging President Trump during the NATO summit in the Netherlands. It is hoped that Zelensky and other leaders effectively conveyed the unacceptability of Putin’s territorial demands – demands that violate Ukraine’s constitution and would result in the abandonment of over 200,000 Ukrainians to Russian occupation, potentially facing death or deportation to Russia’s gulags.
Thus far, President Trump has attempted to appease Putin through flattery and accommodation, a strategy that has failed. Attempts to pressure Zelensky into accepting surrender terms were unsuccessful, even after the U.S. curtailed military and intelligence support. Yet, ukraine continued to fight.
There remains an prospect for meaningful U.S. action.
Despite threats of “crushing” sanctions, Putin secured a summit and a postponement of those sanctions. president Trump has issued another deadline,but the time for deadlines has passed. It is time for action: applying maximum pressure on Putin and the Russian Federation.
Join the conversation: Over 500K national security experts rely on The Cipher Brief for critical insights. Gain full access to what the Experts are reading.
This can be achieved through several steps: first, the President should immediately support the advancement of pending sanctions legislation in Congress, targeting Russia and purchasers of Russian hydrocarbons.
Second, the President should utilize his authority to facilitate the sale or “lend-lease” of military support to Ukraine.
third,the U.S. should remove restrictions on Ukraine’s use of provided weapons systems,allowing Ukraine to take the war to the Russian Federation and demonstrate the consequences to the Russian people.If Putin objects, he should end the war and withdraw.
Fourth, the U.S. should restore Russia’s diplomatic isolation and publicly denounce Russia as the aggressor.
Moreover, the U.S.should leverage its success in resolving the Armenia-Azerbaijan conflict to reduce Russian influence in Georgia, a historically pro-U.S. nation currently facing Russian interference.
Allowing Russia to lose influence in the Caucasus should be added to the list of Putin’s strategic failures, alongside Finland and Sweden’s accession to NATO.
Sanctions alone will not sway Putin, but a combination of sanctions, renewed military and financial support for Ukraine, diplomatic isolation, and strategic leverage on russia’s periphery might.
The path forward should be clear to President Trump,who must now recognize Putin as an enemy and hold him accountable for his actions.
Disclaimer: All statements of fact, opinion, or analysis expressed are those of the author and do not reflect the official positions or views of the U.S.Government. Nothing in the contents should be construed as asserting or implying U.S.Government authentication of data or endorsement of the author’s views.
The Cipher Brief is committed to publishing a range of perspectives on national security issues submitted by deeply experienced national security professionals.
Opinions expressed are those of the author and do not represent the views or opinions of The Cipher Brief.
Share your expertise: Submit your perspective on national security issues to Editor@thecipherbrief.com for potential publication.
Stay informed: Access this week’s Dead Drop – the best national security gossip – with Subscriber+ membership. It’s easy to subscribe.
Read more expert-driven national security insights at The Cipher Brief
