Used Car Import Rules Relaxed: Lobby Group Calls for Change
Clean Car Standard Under Fire: Used Car Importers Claim Scheme Backfiring on Emissions Goals
Table of Contents
New Zealand’s Clean Car Standard, designed to encourage the uptake of low-emission vehicles, is facing criticism from the Imported Motor Vehicle Association (IMVA), who argue the scheme is inadvertently hindering carbon reduction efforts and impacting affordability. The IMVA claims the standard is causing a notable drop in used car imports, possibly leading to older, less efficient vehicles remaining on the road for longer.
Decline in Used Car Imports Sparks Concern
Data from the IMVA reveals a concerning trend: used light-vehicle imports have plummeted 22 percent year-on-year, and are now 25 percent lower than 2023 volumes. While acknowledging global factors contribute to this decline, the association believes the Clean Car Standard is a major driver, disproportionately affecting both vehicle availability and price.
The Clean Car Standard, implemented on January 1, 2023, operates by charging importers of high-emitting vehicles while offering credits for eco-friendly cars. These credits can then be used to offset costs. The intention is to incentivize the import of lower-emission vehicles and accelerate the transition to a greener vehicle fleet in New Zealand.Though, the IMVA contends the current formula used to determine emission targets is flawed. They propose several changes to the standard, including:
Revising the Emission Target Formula: The IMVA argues the current calculation method is overly restrictive.
Lowering Emission Targets: A more achievable target,they believe,would maintain import incentives.
Reducing Penalties: Smaller penalties would prevent vehicles from becoming prohibitively expensive.
The Argument: Holding Onto Older Cars is Worse for the Environment
IMVA Chief executive Officer Greig Epps argues the standard is creating a perverse incentive. “The standard encourages people to buy cars within New Zealand’s current vehicle fleet, rather than import them,” he explains. “That goes against everything we are trying to do with carbon reduction, because the younger the vehicle generally, the more efficient it is and the better for the environment.”
Epps emphasizes that simply extending the lifespan of existing vehicles doesn’t necessarily translate to environmental benefits. If cars are held onto longer, rather than being replaced with newer, more efficient models, the overall impact on emissions reduction is diminished. A consistent turnover to newer vehicles, even if used imports, contributes to a faster reduction in the average emissions of the national fleet.
Government Response and Ongoing Review
Transport Minister Chris bishop acknowledges the decline in used-imported vehicles, noting the trend began as early as 2017. He attributes the decrease to a combination of factors, including rising vehicle prices at Japanese auctions, the current economic climate, and shifting consumer demand.
Bishop stated he is actively seeking further advice on the effectiveness of the Clean Car Standard and whether it is achieving its intended goals. This review will likely consider the concerns raised by the IMVA and assess the broader impact of the scheme on the New Zealand vehicle market and its emissions reduction targets.
What does This Mean for Consumers?
The debate surrounding the Clean Car Standard highlights the complex challenges of transitioning to a lasting transportation system. Consumers may experience:
Limited Choice: Reduced import volumes could lead to fewer options in the used car market.
Higher Prices: Increased costs associated with the standard may be passed on to buyers.
Potential Impact on Affordability: The scheme could make it more challenging for some consumers to access affordable transportation.
The outcome of the government’s review will be crucial in determining the future of the Clean Car Standard and its impact on both the automotive industry and New Zealand’s environmental goals.
Stay informed with our daily newsletter. Sign Up For Informations – curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.