Windows 11 Problems: Creator’s Take & Microsoft Solutions
- Windows 11 is increasingly feeling like an advertising platform, according to Dave Plummer, the original creator of Windows Task Manager.Plummer argues that the proliferation of suggestions and sponsored...
- In a recent YouTube video highlighted by Windows latest, plummer outlined a series of changes he would implement if he led Microsoft's Windows development.
- Plummer identifies several key areas where Windows 11 falls short, notably for those familiar with previous versions of the operating system.
Dave Plummer Critiques Windows 11, Calls for “Windows Expert” Mode
Table of Contents
Windows 11 is increasingly feeling like an advertising platform, according to Dave Plummer, the original creator of Windows Task Manager.Plummer argues that the proliferation of suggestions and sponsored applications erodes user trust and hinders the experience for power users.
In a recent YouTube video highlighted by Windows latest, plummer outlined a series of changes he would implement if he led Microsoft’s Windows development. His core proposal centers around a dedicated “Windows Expert” mode designed to restore control and customization options for experienced users.
Key Issues with Windows 11
Plummer identifies several key areas where Windows 11 falls short, notably for those familiar with previous versions of the operating system. He describes the current approach as “mitten mode,” a restrictive interface intended to simplify the experience for newcomers but frustrating for power users.
His proposed “Windows Expert” mode would address these concerns with the following features:
- Disable Suggestions: Eliminate unsolicited recommendations for Microsoft apps and services.
- Unified Settings: Consolidate settings currently scattered between the Settings app and the traditional Control panel.
- Default Terminal & Winget: Set Windows Terminal as the default console application and integrate Winget for package management.
- Privacy & Telemetry: Enhance privacy tools and provide greater clarity regarding data collection.
- Update Control: Prevent forced updates without explicit user consent.
The Problem of Monetization
Plummer’s most pointed criticism centers on the increasing monetization of the Windows 11 experience. He argues that the operating system has become a “sales channel” for other Microsoft products, a practice he deems disrespectful to users.
“I think we’ve crossed the line over to where the operating system feels like a sales channel for all their other properties. and that’s corrosive in a way that telemetry never will be. When the OS suggests,hey,maybe you should switch browsers after you explicitly chose another one,that’s not onboarding. That’s just disrespect. When the Start Menu shows sponsored apps, you put a price on my attention on my machine.”
Dave plummer
He believes a simple toggle within “Expert mode” could disable the entire suggestion pipeline, but acknowledges that implementing such a change would require internal support and a willingness to prioritize user trust over short-term revenue gains.
A Call for Trust and Control
Plummer’s critique resonates with many users who feel that Windows 11 has strayed from its core purpose of providing a stable and customizable operating system. His call for a dedicated “Expert Mode” reflects a broader desire for greater control and transparency within Windows.
The following table summarizes Plummer’s key recommendations:
| Issue | Proposed Solution |
|---|---|
| Unwanted Suggestions | Disable suggestion pipeline in “Expert Mode” |
| Fragmented Settings | Unify Settings app and Control Panel |
| Limited Console Options | default to Windows Terminal & integrate Winget |
| Privacy Concerns | Improve privacy tools and telemetry transparency |
| Forced Updates | Allow users to control update installation |
While it remains uncertain whether Microsoft will heed Plummer’s advice, his insights offer a valuable perspective on the challenges facing Windows 11 and the importance of prioritizing user experience and trust.