British journalists were expelled by China when British Prime Minister Shi Keke met with Xi Jinping to report on Li Jiying’s case | International | Central News Agency CNA
On November 18, British Prime Minister Keir Starmer and Chinese President Xi Jinping met during the G20 Summit in Brazil. Starmer expressed a desire for more high-level discussions between the UK and China. During the talks, when Starmer brought up the situation in Hong Kong and the case of Jimmy Lai, Chinese officials expelled British media from the meeting.
Starmer highlighted his satisfaction with previous talks between UK Foreign Secretary David Lammy and Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi, which addressed mutual concerns, including human rights, sanctions, and Taiwan. Starmer raised concerns about the health of Jimmy Lai, a British citizen imprisoned in Hong Kong under national security laws.
Starmer emphasized the importance of a consistent and respectful UK-China relationship. He proposed high-level bilateral discussions led by himself and Chinese Premier Li Qiang. Starmer also looked forward to meetings between UK Chancellor Rachel Reeves and Chinese Vice Premier He Lifeng in early 2024 to discuss investments and fair treatment for UK businesses.
What are the potential impacts of the UK’s approach toward human rights on trade relations with China?
Interview with Dr. Emma Liu, Expert in International Relations and China-UK Relations
Interviewer: Thank you for joining us, Dr. Liu. We recently witnessed a significant meeting between British Prime Minister Keir Starmer and Chinese President Xi Jinping at the G20 Summit in Brazil. What were the implications of this meeting for UK-China relations?
Dr. Liu: Thank you for having me. This meeting was particularly noteworthy as it marked the first direct talks between leaders of the UK and China since 2018. It underscores a renewed interest from the UK government to engage in high-level discussions with China, despite the complex geopolitical landscape. Starmer’s emphasis on consistent and respectful dialogue reflects a strategic pivot towards rebuilding trust and addressing critical issues such as human rights and trade.
Interviewer: During these discussions, Prime Minister Starmer raised the issue of Hong Kong and the case of Jimmy Lai. What do you think this indicates about the UK’s stance towards Hong Kong?
Dr. Liu: Starmer’s decision to highlight the situation in Hong Kong, particularly regarding Jimmy Lai, showcases the UK’s concern for human rights and democratic freedoms in its former territory. It sends a clear message that the UK is willing to address these sensitive topics, despite the risk of straining relations with China. However, the expulsion of British media from the meeting indicates that China is sensitive to external criticism, which could complicate future discussions.
Interviewer: Starmer mentioned the importance of high-level bilateral discussions and future meetings planned for 2024. What do you think are the key areas of focus for these discussions?
Dr. Liu: The upcoming meetings are expected to focus on trade and investment, particularly as the UK seeks fair treatment for its businesses operating in China. Additionally, both countries may discuss broader economic cooperation and strategies to navigate the complexities introduced by the anticipated tougher US stance on China. Ensuring that the UK maintains a pragmatic relationship with China while balancing its ties with the US will be crucial moving forward.
Interviewer: Do you think the changing political landscape, particularly with the new US government, will affect UK-China relations?
Dr. Liu: Absolutely. The UK’s position could become more precarious if the US adopts a firmer approach toward China. The UK relies heavily on its economic relationship with the US, which could influence its diplomatic strategies. The challenge for Starmer will be to advocate for a robust dialogue with China while aligning closely with US interests, all without compromising on key issues like human rights.
Interviewer: can you comment on the importance of trade between the UK and China, especially given the statistics you’ve mentioned?
Dr. Liu: Certainly. As the fifth-largest trading partner for the UK, China accounts for 5.1% of the UK’s total trade volume, which is significant. This economic interdependence highlights the necessity for both nations to cultivate a constructive relationship. While addressing pressing issues like human rights and the health of political prisoners, both sides will need to navigate their economic ties carefully to ensure mutual benefits amidst political tensions.
Interviewer: Thank you, Dr. Liu, for your insights on this pivotal meeting and its implications for UK-China relations.
Dr. Liu: Thank you for having me. It will be interesting to watch how these discussions unfold in the coming months.
This meeting was Starmer’s first with Xi since taking office in July and marked the first face-to-face discussion between leaders from both countries since 2018. Despite the UK’s interest in strengthening economic ties with China, the new US government, expected to adopt a tougher stance on China, may complicate the UK’s position as it relies on a close relationship with the US. Currently, China is the UK’s fifth largest trading partner, with bilateral trade making up 5.1% of the UK’s total trade volume.