Elden Ring DLC Nominated for Game of the Year: Controversy and Backlash Explained

Elden Ring DLC Controversy at The Game Awards 2024

The nomination of “Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree” for Game of the Year at The Game Awards 2024 has stirred significant debate. Many gamers are unhappy with this choice. Criticism is primarily directed at Geoff Keighley, the host and organizer of the event.

Greg Miller, a gaming personality, defended the nomination, stating that high-quality DLC should be honored as a game. However, critics argue that DLC should have its separate category, instead of competing for the top prize.

This backlash has persisted since the nomination was announced. Many gamers believe that DLC should not be considered for Game of the Year because it is not a standalone game.

Concerns grew when The Game Awards website recently updated its rules, confirming that DLC can be nominated for Game of the Year if critics support it. Shadow of the Erdtree has received a high score of 94 on Metacritic, suggesting its quality. Yet, some argue its inclusion in the main category undermines other full games nominated alongside it.

This debate brings to light differing opinions on what constitutes a true Game of the Year. While some see value in honoring outstanding DLC, others firmly believe it should remain separate.

The ongoing conversation raises questions about the criteria for such awards and the future of nominations at The Game Awards. Gamers are encouraged to share their views on this matter. Should DLC ever be considered for Game of the Year? The responses reveal a clear divide in gamer opinions.