Moral Scrupulosity: How to Be Good Without Ruining Your Life
- This article explores the idea that striving for perfect morality is not only unrealistic but also needless, and even counter to God's preference for humanity.
- humans: Angels exist in a simplified moral universe,but human ethics are complex and frequently enough involve conflicting values.God chose humans despite this messiness, indicating an embrace of our...
- * "The Mindful Self-Compassion Workbook" by Kristin Neff and Chris germer: A resource for developing self-compassion.
Summary of the Article: Embracing “Good Enough” - A Lesson from Yom Kippur
This article explores the idea that striving for perfect morality is not only unrealistic but also needless, and even counter to God’s preference for humanity. The author draws on a rabbinic understanding of Yom Kippur as a happy day, becuase God willingly accepts flawed, “messy” humans.
Here are the key takeaways:
* angels vs. humans: Angels exist in a simplified moral universe,but human ethics are complex and frequently enough involve conflicting values.God chose humans despite this messiness, indicating an embrace of our inherent imperfection.
* Don’t Out-Zeal God: The author urges readers not to hold themselves to a higher standard than God does. God accepts our imperfect actions.
* Release the Arrow: We should strive to make the best decisions we can, but once a decision is made and acted upon, we need to accept the outcome, even if it’s not optimal.
* Human Limitations: We are not perfect optimizing machines. We lack the ability to foresee all consequences or perfectly balance competing values. Doing our best is sufficient.
* “Good Enough” is Enough: The core message is that striving for perfection is detrimental.God finds our best efforts “good enough,” and we should extend that same grace to ourselves.
Bonus Recommendations:
The author also recommends:
* “The Mindful Self-Compassion Workbook” by Kristin Neff and Chris germer: A resource for developing self-compassion.
* The Centre for Mindful Self-compassion: Offers an eight-week self-compassion course.
In essence, the article is a powerful argument for self-compassion and a rejection of the paralyzing pursuit of moral perfection. It suggests that embracing our humanity, flaws and all, is not just acceptable, but desired by a loving God.
