NYC Mayor’s Grocery Plan Draws Scrutiny as Competitors Launch Similar Initiatives
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s proposal for city-operated grocery stores, a key pledge during his campaign, is facing a curious backdrop as other companies launch similar, albeit temporary, initiatives. The mayor’s plan, designed to combat rising food costs and address food insecurity, aims to establish five city-run grocery stores – one in each borough.
According to the New York state comptroller’s office, food costs in New York City rose 65.8% between 2013 and 2023, outpacing broader inflation. Mamdani’s proposal centers on the city avoiding rent and property taxes, allowing for wholesale purchasing and partnerships with local neighborhoods to determine product selection. The estimated annual cost to operate the five stores is approximately $60 million.
This week, Polymarket, a cryptocurrency-based prediction market, announced the opening of “New York City’s first free grocery store,” a move seemingly inspired by Mamdani’s plan. Polymarket stated its intention to “empower every New Yorker to achieve food security for good” and donated $1 million to the Food Bank for NYC. However, the Polymarket store is planned as a temporary pop-up, with the location yet to be announced, and is scheduled to open on February 12.
Mamdani responded to Polymarket’s announcement with a post referencing a satirical headline from Clickhole: “Heartbreaking: the worst person you know just made a great point.”
Polymarket isn’t the only company to recently experiment with free grocery provisions. Kalshi, a competitor to Polymarket, offered free groceries, up to $50 per shopper, at Westside Market in New York City’s East Village on February 3.
Mamdani, who became mayor on January 1, 2026, is the city’s first Muslim and South Asian mayor. During his inauguration, he vowed to represent all New Yorkers and govern “audaciously.”
The concept of city-operated grocery stores isn’t unique to New York. Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson previously pursued a similar plan, but his administration has since shifted focus to a year-round public market, the Chicago Tribune.
Mamdani’s proposal has already sparked debate. During the campaign, he argued that the city-owned stores would address “market failure” in low-income neighborhoods where access to affordable, fresh food is limited. According to the City Council, more than 30% of residents in many of these neighborhoods experience food insecurity.
The mayor’s office and Polymarket have been contacted for comment.
