Pro-Palestine Conference Leaders Sue Berlin Officials
- Organisers of a pro-palestine conference are suing the Berlin authorities after the event was shut down by police on April 12, 2024, shortly after it began.
- The State of Berlin argues that police acted lawfully, preemptively shutting down the conference due to predictions of criminal activity.
- Michael Ploese, the lawyer representing the conference organisers, argues that german law only permits restrictions on gatherings in private spaces when there is a high probability of a...
“`html
What Happened?
Organisers of a pro-palestine conference are suing the Berlin authorities after the event was shut down by police on April 12, 2024, shortly after it began. The conference, known as the Palestine Congress, was a forum for solidarity activists and human rights experts to discuss Israel’s actions in Gaza and Germany’s alleged complicity.Police in riot gear descended on the venue, cutting off power to prevent speeches from being heard or broadcast.
Why Was the Conference Shut Down?
The State of Berlin argues that police acted lawfully, preemptively shutting down the conference due to predictions of criminal activity. Specifically, authorities anticipated potential incitement to hatred, dissemination of propaganda, or the use of symbols of unconstitutional and “terrorist” organisations. This prediction was partly based on the organisers’ alleged failure to distance themselves from the Hamas-led incursion into southern Israel on October 7, 2023, during a pre-event news conference.
Legal Arguments and Perspectives
Michael Ploese, the lawyer representing the conference organisers, argues that german law only permits restrictions on gatherings in private spaces when there is a high probability of a criminal act. He contends that the right to freedom of expression should generally take precedence. He stated, “I’m not aware of any other instance where a conference was shut down without any crime having been committed.”
The authorities maintain their actions were justified to prevent potential violations of German law prohibiting hate speech and support for terrorist organisations.
Who is Involved?
Key parties involved include:
- Conference Organisers: A collective of solidarity activists and human rights experts.
- Juedische Stimme (Jewish Voice): A German group affiliated with the US collective of the same name, representing jewish peace activists critical of israeli actions. Wieland Hoban, the chair of Juedische Stimme, was among the speakers.
- The State of Berlin: The defendant in the lawsuit, represented by legal counsel defending the police’s actions.
- Berlin Police: The officers who carried out the shutdown of the conference.
Context and Background
This case occurs within a broader context of increasing scrutiny and restrictions on pro-Palestinian activism in germany. German authorities have historically maintained a strong stance in support of Israel, and criticism of Israeli policies is often met with accusations of antisemitism. The shutdown of the Palestine Congress has sparked debate about the balance between protecting freedom of speech and preventing hate speech.