2025 MLB Rookie of the Year Predictions: Top Prospects to Watch

The MLB Pipeline Podcast discussed potential Rookie of the Year candidates for 2025. Jim Callis and Jonathan Mayo shared their top picks after successfully predicting winners in previous years.

Top Prospects for 2025:

1. Dylan Crews, OF

   • Rank: WSH No. 1, MLB No. 1
   • Callis & Mayo: Both selected Crews. He has a secure spot in the Nationals’ outfield, and his experience in 2024 prepares him well for a strong season.

2. Matt Shaw, INF

   • Rank: CHC No. 1, MLB No. 22
   • Callis: Thinks he won’t make the Opening Day roster but believes he will excel quickly in his professional career.
   • Mayo: Agrees, stating Shaw will hit his way into the Cubs lineup and make a significant impact.

3. Bubba Chandler, RHP

   • Rank: PIT No. 1, MLB No. 15
   • Mayo: Expects Chandler to join the Pirates’ rotation by May after a strong finish in 2024.

4. Andrew Painter, RHP

   • Rank: PHI No. 2, MLB No. 32
   • Callis: Believes Painter will make a difference for the Phillies, though he may not be on the Opening Day roster.

5. Coby Mayo, 3B/1B

   • Rank: BAL No. 1, MLB No. 8
   • Callis & Mayo: Both predict Mayo will hit around 26 home runs in 2025 if he finds his way into the lineup.

6. Jackson Jobe, RHP

   • Rank: DET No. 1, MLB No. 5
   • Mayo: Anticipates Jobe will significantly impact the Tigers’ pitching after their 2024 success.

7. Jasson Domínguez, OF

   • Rank: NYY No. 1, MLB No. 14
   • Callis: Expects the Yankees to ensure Domínguez gets regular playing time.
8. Jacob Wilson, SS
   • Rank: ATH No. 1, MLB No. 24
   • Callis: Praises Wilson’s consistent hitting and fielding ability, despite some injury setbacks.

This overview highlights notable names and expectations for the upcoming MLB season, with insights from experts on potential impacts each player could have on their teams.